what makes you suspect shraeye the most? i'm realizing i'm generally better at evaluating other peoples cases/reasonings than i am at actually reading/judging people.
What makes you unwilling to vote for shraeye?
Robz, I'm also curious about this and (spoiler) Eevee is sneaking up my scumlist.
Is it because I was sleeping?
Phone posting, will be around later. Town read on Galz and Grujah, of course both could be scum. My brother is giving a sincere defense, but he could still be scum. Rarae has made herself a lot less suspicious by posting more... But it wasn't super substantive.
I'm feeling best about a shraeye lynch at the moment. Who is with me?
I often fall in this caveat, but the recent attacks on me kinda scummified him in my eyes :s He is also seeing triples, just like mcmcalot, but shra should know better by now. Going out-there with triples and no info to back it up D1 - really?
That's the nature of this setup. I've played as VT once, as scum once, and as IC once. If you aren't looking for the entire team, you're gonna miss things. When you find a suspect, you HAVE to ask yourself if this person is actually scum, who are their partners, and who is on my team?
Scumteams have been called in this setup before, but I'm not sure if it was by day 1 or not. It's a lot easier than in a real game; this setup is very unique.
I disagree with this a lot. I think finding possibilities "either is scum" or "both cant be scum" is the way to go in this setup, not calling out entire teams.
Surprised to see so little activity during my sleep (10 hours, YAY!). So, thoughts on everyone, I thought I'd make a list like this before seeing Grujah asked me for one so I thought about the game when I was lying in bed and waking up. So this is mostly based on the first 9 pages with the last page freshly read in mind as well:
Eevee: It's me, Eevee!
Insomniac & Robz: Good solid IC-game, seal of approval.
Galzria: I think the first half of the game was such a classic town Galz (I didn't realize this in the heat of the moment, but thinking back dude had like half the posts and was just everywhere, that's the town Galz I know and love having as an IC to lead things). His level of activity has since dropped, but to lurky levels. I'll call him a light town read, there are 5 players out of whom 3 are mafia so 60 being the standard, Galz gets a 55.
mcmcmsalot: Probably my strongest town read, largely because of the emotion-read I explained earlier. I have a little brother myself, I think it's pretty solid. 45.
shraeye: I know I suspected him earlier, but thinking about it, I was just irritated because I thought he was unnecessarily mean to Galzria and also really wrong. This reminds me of the town shraeye in Robz's megamafia. By now I should know shraeye plays scum VERY well and fooled me hardcore in the game someone referenced earlier, but even there he seemed different and somehow.. friendlier? So I think both analytical and emotional analysis leads to a town read on shraeye. 50.
Grujah: I've never been good at reading Grujah. He hasn't done much anything I can remember, apart from asking some questions which can be read as an easy way to contribute without really saying much (I don't remember where this falls in Grujah's meta though). I feel I always have this "slightly scummy" read on him, so this is probably of not much help, but PoE 70 because others have seemed townier.
raerae: Top scum read. Robz's assessment of her play "trying to sound like she was as an IC" resonates with me. It could be that she was drunk or that she was under pressure for the first time, I don't know. Would be helpful to get her to post before making a decision, it's unfortunate she won't. (deadline in 2 hours? holy!) Still, even her self-summary seemed scummy to me, so I'm definitely most okay with her lynch. 75
We are going to a restaurant in 1 hour, I'll be here until then and possibly phone posting a bit from there after that. After we come home, I'll have great availability day 2 seeing how I just woke up and won't go anywhere today.
Author
Topic: ZMIX - Veterans Go Flavorless (Mafia wins flawlessly) (Read 47424 times)