I'm back with a reads post, as promised. I was going to do this last night but I passed out like an old man!
Archetype: I have a tough time reading this guy, and apparently he will post more starting soon. Obviously the most notable thing is the wagon that ran up on him. I admit that when I first saw his "If ash doesn't get killed N1 -> we can lynch him!" post, I too thought that it looked pretty scummy. But then that "jokey" wagon ran up on him frighteningly fast, and while I believe most of that wagon is jokey, I do think it's likely there's scum on there. So I end up on null-to-scummy on Arch.
chairs: Has got the whole stump!claim thing going on. As I said, I believe it for now, and it's obviously something we should test tomorrow if he's still alive.
sudgy: Still a scumread. Sparse, contentless posts that are quick to point out how jokey they are.
Walrus: Practically an IC at this point
Jimmmmm: Relatively active, relatively short, pointed posts, often phrased as questions. I don't know Jimmmmm very well, but this basically matches up with what I expected...I'll say null-to-town for now.
xeiron: A few people voted for him. But honestly I'm not seeing a whole lot there. As I said, I actually *agreed* with his initial allegation against Archetype, and then some other people glommed on the wagon just to be "funny". So I like the fact that he was actually trying to scumhunt, and I don't blame him for the Archetype vote. I'm going to say town read on xeiron for now.
ashersky: A lot has been said about him and his claim. It's a tricky spot, but if I had to guess I would still lean town. I was only half-joking about that time travel plan, you know, I think it might be possible to actually kajigger something like that.
faust: Seems relatively towny to me. This guy seems to get mislynched a lot lately. I'm not saying you should discount a scumread on him if you have one. But I do think that from what I've seen, a good way to smell a D1 mislynch is if it seems too "easy". We should have to fight for a lynch, because scum will do their best to fight against it. The easy compromises too often flip town. Anyway that was a bit of a tangent, but I bring it up because I feel faust has fallen victim to this a lot.
Galzria: Currently lost in the Delta quadrant. He was able to use an unstable micro-wormhole to make contact with Earth for 86 seconds, but so far regular communication has been impossible. Too little data to go by, although I did get a good feeling from his one substantial post.
e: Not as active as I would have expected. He has one big, long, quotey, e-ish post about the setup, but that's really it. Idk, doesn't feel quite right...I'll say mild scum read here.
EFHW: Literally an IC at this point
PPS: I really want to say town read for his high level of activity and discussion. But am I remembering correctly that in Monster Madness Mafia, he was scum, right? And he had me completely fooled, because he was similarly active. So he had me really fooled there, but that game didn't go on for very long, and maybe he was just good at scum. Let's say mild town read.
nkirbit: Among the lurkiest, first of all, although that by itself could go either way. Something about it doesn't quite add up for me either...he expresses doubt about the claims a lot, he says "could be town ash, could be scum ash", and then goes to ash being his top town read the next day, after ash calls him potentially scummy. His longest post is whether scum would prepare a rationale for a claim, but that sort of seems like the sort of thing scum would think about. So I could see scum here I guess.
jotheonah: Quite active, although some of his posts are a little fluffy. Null read I guess, with an edge towards town.
I meant to say playing there. Not sheeping. Not a sheep. Bah.
SHEEPSLIP?!?!?!?!?
So I guess at the end of the day that leaves me with sudgy and nkirbit as top scumreads. In fact, I'll go ahead and
vote: nkirbit
Author
Topic: RMM12: Time War Mafia (Game Over - Town + Survivor win!) (Read 157320 times)