Okay, so one of {Faust, Ash, Hydrad} is scum?
So, 8 alive, 2 scum. Faust gets his wish and lynches me today, I flip town, BA is confirmed town. Night kill, 6 alive, 2 scum. Now this is MyLo. Who would scum!Faust try to mislynch here? Whoever in {Ash, PPS, Lio} isn't his partner I guess. Is this a good scum strategy? Maybe. A stronger one, I think, would to argue for the mislynch out of {Ash, PPS, Lio, Hydrad, Archetype} today and then try to mislynch me/BA for the win.
I think scum!Faust would know we're telling the truth and not argue against us so much. Though the "okay we'll lynch Ash but if he's town definitely lynch WW/BA" thing is worrysome, basically trying to set up the two mislynches needed to win.
So now.. Hydrad is the only unconfirmed player that knew Ichi was in the council. Does scum see an advantage to killing Ichi because of the council? Maybe they thought it would be a lot harder to push for mislynching me and BA with two players verifying what was said in the council. But Hydrad has been saying BA and I are believable, and his attitude towards BA and myself sounds more genuine than faked.. for this to be reasonable it would have to be BA/Faust with BA arguing for us as town and Faust arguing for us as scum. I'm having trouble seeing this as a very reasonable strategy.
Ichi was a self-proclaimed IC, and wasn't getting a lot of suspicion, so that could explain the kill easily enough.
Ash has just been all kinds of suspicious.. hammering Volt being among the top things. He'd still be my pick within {Ash, Hydrad, Faust}. Then again, it's silly for scum!Ash to lie now and create a 1-1 type of thing (or 1-1-1 type of thing). Scum!Ash would know Hydrad was the target of the attack, and he'd have to know that it would be {Ash, Hydrad, Faust} and he'd be the most suspicious. Maybe he thought he was screwed so he had to try something.
Ash also had little or nothing to say about BA and I being Town, so that's suspicious.
My preference in the set is Ash > Faust > Hydrad.