Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[MiX]

You most likely want to redirect to someone that's dead, can you do that?

Why would that be? Fixing isn't a targeted action, it cannot be blocked or redirected.

Did you read that correctly?

[faust]

You most likely want to redirect to someone that's dead, can you do that?

Why would that be? Fixing isn't a targeted action, it cannot be blocked or redirected.

Did you read that correctly?

Ah, sorry, makes more sense now. I thought you were intending to stop the fixing of joth, which would be cool but unfortunately does not work.

[MiX]

You most likely want to redirect to someone that's dead, can you do that?

Why would that be? Fixing isn't a targeted action, it cannot be blocked or redirected.

Did you read that correctly?

Ah, sorry, makes more sense now. I thought you were intending to stop the fixing of joth, which would be cool but unfortunately does not work.

Yeah, I wish. I think day roleblockers can do that, however.

[scolapasta]

Scola, we’re still waiting for the “later”

Yeah, after posting my "spoiler" I realized that was the gist of what I wanted to say.

At least 1 of MiX and Didds is scum. I think maybe both.

I am not yet convinced there are scum humans. Though I still don't see how joth expects to get rezzed then. Maybe a host dying twice is some kind of trigger for something to happen? I don't know.

MiX seems to really want to know if I am human/host and is threatening to vig me if I don't reveal.  This seems very boldly scummy to me.

I honestly think it is better for town right now that I don't reveal. (except for MiX's threat, which actually increases my belief)

I want to hear from the three known humans if they think I should reveal. As there is at least 1 town in them (if not all 3), that will help me understand if other town think there's a reason for me to reveal.

[faust]

At least 1 of MiX and Didds is scum. I think maybe both.

Do you think there is any dead scum besides joth?

[WestCoastDidds]

Redirecting is tricky. I don’t want you (Mix) not to get rezzed, and I didn’t want to mess with what yams or faust might be doing to protect me. My biggest concern was getting whacked last night.

[WestCoastDidds]

Scola, why do you think either Mix or I are scum?

The only way it could possibly be true that BOTH of us are scum is if you are a town host. Otherwise it’s game over.

[scolapasta]

At least 1 of MiX and Didds is scum. I think maybe both.

Do you think there is any dead scum besides joth?

ADK? I see it plausible that there could be 4 scum, especially since scum host seem unable to kill humans, so you'd have to buff them somehow.

[MiX]

Scola, why do you think either Mix or I are scum?

[scolapasta]

Scola, why do you think either Mix or I are scum?

I'm pretty sure I've answered. I'm going on the hypothesis that all scum are hosts. So a) there need to be some more and b) you both seem keenly interested in learning my "humanity".

[MiX]

Scola, why do you think either Mix or I are scum?

I'm pretty sure I've answered. I'm going on the hypothesis that all scum are hosts. So a) there need to be some more and b) you both seem keenly interested in learning my "humanity".

If we are scum, we shot you last night, ergo we know you're human.

Why are you not claiming?

[WestCoastDidds]

Scola, why do you think either Mix or I are scum?

I'm pretty sure I've answered. I'm going on the hypothesis that all scum are hosts. So a) there need to be some more and b) you both seem keenly interested in learning my "humanity".

I don’t want Mix to shoot you just to find out if you are a host

[faust]

At least 1 of MiX and Didds is scum. I think maybe both.

Do you think there is any dead scum besides joth?

ADK? I see it plausible that there could be 4 scum, especially since scum host seem unable to kill humans, so you'd have to buff them somehow.

No way are there 4 scum.

[faust]

Scola, why do you think either Mix or I are scum?

I'm pretty sure I've answered. I'm going on the hypothesis that all scum are hosts. So a) there need to be some more and b) you both seem keenly interested in learning my "humanity".

You can only reasonably hold this belief if you are a host, so I guess this is a claim?

[faust]

I'm also interested in your humanity by the way.

[WestCoastDidds]

He has to be a host, none of his assumptions make sense otherwise.

[scolapasta]

I'm also interested in your humanity by the way.

OK, let's hear from the other humans too.

[scolapasta]

Scola, why do you think either Mix or I are scum?

I'm pretty sure I've answered. I'm going on the hypothesis that all scum are hosts. So a) there need to be some more and b) you both seem keenly interested in learning my "humanity".

You can only reasonably hold this belief if you are a host, so I guess this is a claim?

Why? It may not be both MiX and Didds - or maybe it's not ADK.

But why not 4 scum hosts?

[scolapasta]

He has to be a host, none of his assumptions make sense otherwise.

I'll post the question to you too, why not?

[LaLight]

I'm also interested in your humanity by the way.

OK, let's hear from the other humans too.

Yes, you should claim. Also MiX can not possible be scum, who would kill him?

[WestCoastDidds]

I don’t see how Scola being stubborn about this is pro-town.  MiX will have to shoot him to know if he’s telling the truth, leaving Scola vulnerable to the massacre if Scola gets revived

He’s been pushing all scum are hosts for awhile, which makes sense if he is a town host. If he’s scum, he could be host or human. If he’s human he’s not afraid of the shot.

PPE: if your argument is that MiX and I are both scum, you have to be a town host otherwise the game would have ended as no town hosts would be alive

[LaLight]

And also, scum dayvig is super OP

[faust]

Scola, why do you think either Mix or I are scum?

I'm pretty sure I've answered. I'm going on the hypothesis that all scum are hosts. So a) there need to be some more and b) you both seem keenly interested in learning my "humanity".

You can only reasonably hold this belief if you are a host, so I guess this is a claim?

Why? It may not be both MiX and Didds - or maybe it's not ADK.

But why not 4 scum hosts?

There needs to be at least 1 town host still around, otherwise town's win condition is not reachable.

[WestCoastDidds]

Okay, let’s figure this out....

Scum Scola says that all scum are hosts. What would be the play? Exile one of us so there is time to rezz Joth and massacre?

[faust]

I'm also interested in your humanity by the way.

OK, let's hear from the other humans too.

Yes, you should claim. Also MiX can not possible be scum, who would kill him?

joth. I mean, that's clearly not impossible. It is virtually certain that scum shot scum at some point in this game.