So strange. ashersky, who is generally known for having plans, just opens this game by stumbling into playing dice. Lots of people are new to the mechanic, ashersky! Don't you think it would have been beneficial to discuss strategy for dice rolls before just starting with it? Seems like a good way for scum to force newer players to act without thinking things through, so slight scum read on ashersky.
I rolled immediately as everyone should. We have a measley 389 to the 1000 health of the Troll. Scum really wants the monster to win. This was the case in the first version, too.
This is a closed setup, and I preferred no setup discussion/claiming on D1. But of course, this is f.ds mafia. We've seen this a million times, and yet it keeps happening. Heck, I think mods can easily design against the meta, and do.
Rolling and playing our dice is something we have a choice to do, and that we should do, and so that's a clear sign of scumminess one way or the other. We could do other regular game things, like RVS, or discuss the rolls. And then lead to a D1 lynch that gives us information.
But no, someone will need to foist a mass claim/partial claim/planned claim plan thing and we'll all follow it or not, and then we'll get much less out of our lynch in the end.
So that's cool.