No, actually listen to my arguments and forget gut reads.
- Jimmm has been lurking more in all the other threads. It has seemed to me like he has participated here to best of his abilities.
- Ins copypasted the same message to all his games. Obviously something bad happened and I hope everything/everyone is / will be fine. Sounds like it's nothing super devastating, which is at least good. However, that has nothing to do with his alignment here, literally zero. If he is the best lynch for our faction, i don't think there is anything wrong with lynching him. SfS won't have trouble finding a replacement if that is needed.
Gut reads are gut reads, I do like them too but you know people get them wrong, it's complicated. Especially so when dealig with a group of players this strong. So, unless we can find a motive for Robz's and Galzria's fight being staged, I think it's safe to assume they wouldn't do it for just no reason (right?), so as long as you trust me to be town, we can lynch Jimmm and Ins in whatever order and win. 100%. All we need to do is know I'm town (a leap for you, but one you seem to be willing to take) and that Robz and Galz wouldn't a) stage a fight for no reason and b) have no motive to stage a fight.
Am I missing something?