There's no option for "I would read in it and would probably post in it, but I think it's a bad idea."
Option 7 "I think it's a bad idea" would be the most appropriate for you, then. I see you haven't voted yet, make your voice heard!
I'm going to leave this poll up for another couple of days, but it certainly looks like The Tribe Has Spoken™. I think I know what I want to do about this, but I don't want to get ahead of myself.
For my own curiosity, and perhaps the curiosity of others (and for no other reason whatsoever), I'd sort of like to know the answer to the following question(s). If you meet the conditions, your response would be appreciated.
If you voted "I think it's a bad idea" AND the ONLY reason you think it's a bad idea is because you believe it will divide the community (or something along those lines), then how would you answer these questions?
A. If, in theory, there was a way to have moderated discussion here without the use of a separate sub-board or something, but rather in separate threads, would that make you happy with moderated discussion on F.DS? You can assume this method works perfectly for this question (the next question deals with if it doesn't).
2. If you answered "yes" to A, does this look anything like a [serious] tag or is it something different? Obviously details of the [serious] tag are not agreed upon, but if a [serious] tag doesn't solve this issue for you, that's what I want to know.