Fairly certain most of you have made up your mind about me, but regardless, here's your answer.
First, assume I'm town for this explanation. Like I said, I'm fairly certain you have made up your mind, but anyway, put this in a town!ash context, okay?
By the end of Day 3, the game state was every player having claimed except for me. Of course, that's sort of scummy, as has been pointed out. But, again, assume I’m town. What’s scum thinking at this point?
They know I’m town, and they know I’ve managed to make it through everything without claiming at all. What town players don’t like claiming? The ones with strong PRs.
Now, you also can assume I’m not anyone’s top town read and unlikely to be protected or helped. My goal was to be scum’s nightkill on N3. Secondarily, I figured they may target me with one of their powers, including affecting/stealing/destroying my dice.
So, with those things in mind, I looked at the Love Doctor’s options. At first, I was just going to ignore him. I had 4 dice, so the 1-day options were all that were available. I didn’t want to actively gain Hated in exchange for dice that would possibly be stolen, or go to waste when I died. Loved wasn’t doing me anything, and it generally anti-town, unless I could setup a derphammer that failed and caught scum. I originally chose to discard 2 dice, since that's 2 dice left to be stolen...
But then I looked at the other options (5 dice). I asked the mod if I could select an option I couldn’t afford. The answer was yes, but that I would pay however many dice I could pay and would not receive the reward if I couldn’t afford it. Here was my answer! A way to get rid of my supply dice without affecting the game state.
So I selected Permanently Loved, knowing I would lose my 4 dice and not affecting my lynch status. Now, scum couldn’t steal my dice, which was my only worry. Another thing we don’t know that we haven’t (publicly) taken into consideration was what if scum gain the supply dice of their nightkills? As I expected to die, I didn’t want that happening.
So, there's the full explanation for how the Love Doctor resulted in me having no supply dice today.