Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[silverspawn]

This is a bad defense, because it's too defensive and feels too much pressure against what's just a simple vote in a reads list.

Do you know what this feels like to me? Most likely you do not. Do you want to know? Who am I even talking to? Anyway, it feels like iguanda came into this like "yeah, I'm going to be the towniest scum ever and make it until the end, let's goooo" and now he's like "wait I should be super towny, and that guy suspects me? Let's shoot it down in its roots!"

[silverspawn]

I know because that's exactly how I felt in ASOIAF Mafia. Wanting to put in all the effort and be the towniest guy ever but was immediately suspected. Then I overreacted to my first vote. I didn't live very long.

[silverspawn]

Haddock's reads list feels forced. He's the other scum.

Hah, game solved!

[silverspawn]

 

[Joseph2302]

Haddock's reads list feels forced. He's the other scum.

Hah, game solved!

Who's the third under this logic?
ii and Haddock are only 2.

[silverspawn]

Haddock's reads list feels forced. He's the other scum.

Hah, game solved!

Who's the third under this logic?
ii and Haddock are only 2.

oh. well idk. isn't calling two scum good enough at this point?

[Awaclus]

Haddock's reads list feels forced. He's the other scum.

Hah, game solved!

Who's the third under this logic?
ii and Haddock are only 2.

oh. well idk. isn't calling two scum good enough at this point?

Why are you calling scum good? And no, it's not enough. 

[Joseph2302]

Haddock's reads list feels forced. He's the other scum.

Hah, game solved!

Who's the third under this logic?
ii and Haddock are only 2.

oh. well idk. isn't calling two scum good enough at this point?

Why are you calling scum good? And no, it's not enough. 

2 is good enough for now if true.

What do you think of Gkrieg? There's a potential wagon forming there (3 votes currently).

[Awaclus]

2 is good enough for now if true.

The joke is that "isn't calling two scum good enough" can be parsed like "isn't it good enough to call two scum" or "isn't it enough to call two scum good".

What do you think of Gkrieg? There's a potential wagon forming there (3 votes currently).

I'm not currently voting for him. That's what I think.

[J Reggie]

Woah, a lot happened overnight. It looks like people are starting to believe me about ii, just as I was starting to believe him. I need to wake up before I can figure this out.

[Joseph2302]

2 is good enough for now if true.

The joke is that "isn't calling two scum good enough" can be parsed like "isn't it good enough to call two scum" or "isn't it enough to call two scum good".

What do you think of Gkrieg? There's a potential wagon forming there (3 votes currently).

I'm not currently voting for him. That's what I think.

Fair enough.

Bad quoting by me, the question was actually aimed at ss.

ss, what do you think of Gkrieg?

[J Reggie]

Here is my conclusion:

e is spot on. iguanda is scum. vote: iguanda

This isn't a fakehammer. Did you spell his name wrong on purpose?

[J Reggie]

I still think gkrieg is town, for whatever that's worth. It's still too early in the day for me to process the whole ii - e thing.

[pingpongsam]

Haddock's reads list feels forced. He's the other scum.

Hah, game solved!

Who's the third under this logic?
ii and Haddock are only 2.

Calling the scum team on D1 is my job and clearly you are the other scum member so, there's your team.

[gkrieg13]

My vote is pretty buried in the wall of text there.

vote: gkrieg

Didn't quote the other post because I'm on mobile and didn't want to erase the irrelevant text.

But really!?!?!?!?

Your case on me is that I'm flying under the radar???

I fake hammered someone. One does not fly under the radar and appear to be careful when they cause the biggest thing that happened this game. I've also had many posts with content, which I'm trying to do more of lately. I stated lots of my reads as they were developing which I think moves the game along. It at least forces people to think about my reads or comment on them.

If you have a different case on me then fine, you can vote for me, but you'll have to do a lot better than what you have currently posted.

[Seprix]

Wow, so much going on in D1. I absolutely love this. Reading now.

[Seprix]

e's latest posts look more town, and he has owned up to his mistakes. I would still be 100% fine lynching e, but I think we can find out even more D1. I am curious about the case on Iguana, and I don't think there's any real case on gkreig at all.

[Seprix]

Haddock's reads list feels forced. He's the other scum.

Sorry, Haddock. I am with SS on this. The gkrieg vote isn't a good one.

[silverspawn]

What do you think of Gkrieg? There's a potential wagon forming there (3 votes currently).

town! Pretty firmly so after his latest post.

[Seprix]

I'm not sold Haddock is scum as SS is. I've looked over all of the posts again, I still want an e lynch. It would reveal tons of information, much more than a Joseph lynch, and I still think scum!e is very likely.

[Haddock]

Call my reads wrong all you like, they usually are. But they're not forced.

I did completely forget and then subsequently miss that it was gkrieg who did that fake hammer.   That changes things a bit. My gut is still telling me something about gkrieg though. 
And his vote on Joseph is bad start to finish. 

Gimme a couple of hours and I'll find some time to try to put together a better case on gkrieg.  If I find I can't do better than "bad votes on joseph+gut" then obviously I'll move my vote.

[Seprix]

I also want to see more content from EgorK and chairs. They're practically invisible.

[silverspawn]

Call my reads wrong all you like, they usually are. But they're not forced.

I didn't call them wrong at all. Just forced.

[Haddock]

Call my reads wrong all you like, they usually are. But they're not forced.

I didn't call them wrong at all. Just forced.

And I'm telling you they're not forced.  To my surprise, actually.  Usually I have to force myself pretty hard to have reads on D1 at all.

[silverspawn]

Here is my conclusion:

e is spot on. iguanda is scum. vote: iguanda

This isn't a fakehammer. Did you spell his name wrong on purpose?

there is no d in his name! 

erm, no. maybe that's a sign? Let's vote: Haddock instead.

No... stupid idea. vote: iguana

It might very well have counted anyway, btw. That's up to the mod's discretion.