Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Robz888]

Vote Count 6.Final

faust (3): Galzria, RoadRunner7671, Teproc
Galzria (1): faust

With 4 alive it took 3 to lynch. Day 6 ends Thursday, October 26 at 5:00 PM.

ALERT ALERT: DHARMA INITIATIVE EMERGENCY. THE HOSTILES HAVE BREACHED THE PERIMETER. The Hostiles have...

Oh, you seem to have lynched a suspect. But were you right? If not, there's a mass grave waiting with our names on it...

Faust has been crossed off Jacob's List. He was Walt Lloyd, the Others Goon.

GAME OVER. CRASH SURVIVORS WIN! NAMASTE.

[Teproc]

Yay !

[silverspawn]

I didn't follow the game much, but it is pretty great if you think really hard and long about something and end up being right. Well done!

2400 posts seems worthy of the setup.

[Teproc]

faust was a Goon ? Who did e block then ?

I did think scum not claiming Roleblocker was weird but between that and N1, I was sure there was a roleblocker...

[Teproc]

I didn't follow the game much, but it is pretty great if you think really hard and long about something and end up being right. Well done!

2400 posts seems worthy of the setup.

Yes, nothing more satistying. I think it's the first time I get it right at lylo, too. Not that I was needed, since RR and Galz were on it anyway.

[Witherweaver]

Neat.

[Galzria]

Geeeeeezzzz... I was nervous for a scum!RR lol.

Yaaay! This was a hair-thinning game!

[Galzria]

https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/NXuscBFYmEUW

My QT, wherein I call the entire scum team N3, but don't have any confidence in my reads the entire game.

[Galzria]

For the record:

On the topic of QT quoting - I wasn't around for the game Teproc referenced. Back when we played before, linking from personal QT's was acceptable. I believe Robz missed out on the issues that presents as well, and thus, like me, harking back to a time long ago didn't forsee the problem.

I DO see the issues with it - however exactly where a line should be drawn is tough. No quoting from any QT's? Ok, fine. I'll write all my night thoughts in a separate notepad and post from there. No quoting from any outside sources? Ok, I'll write my night thoughts in a game thread post box and choose whether or not I want to post them once the day starts.

I'm not trying to "break" a system that I think is a good one to have... but where is the line drawn?

[Galzria]

I didn't follow the game much, but it is pretty great if you think really hard and long about something and end up being right. Well done!

2400 posts seems worthy of the setup.

Yes, nothing more satistying. I think it's the first time I get it right at lylo, too. Not that I was needed, since RR and Galz were on it anyway.

It's harder for you than it is for us. We're looking at only two scenarios. You've still got 3 to consider.

[Galzria]

I didn't follow the game much, but it is pretty great if you think really hard and long about something and end up being right. Well done!

2400 posts seems worthy of the setup.

Yes, nothing more satistying. I think it's the first time I get it right at lylo, too. Not that I was needed, since RR and Galz were on it anyway.

It's harder for you than it is for us. We're looking at only two scenarios. You've still got 3 to consider.

And once RR was ruled out, Faust and I had default votes. You still needed to figure it out.

[Robz888]

1. Datswan - 8
2. Jimmmm - 15
3. Space - 16
4. Galzria - 42
5. Teproc - 7
6. Lalight - 14
7. Roadrunner - 35
8. IDP - 51
9. 2.7 - 73
10. Faust - 23
11. Gkrieg - 23
12. Qvist - 5
13. Eevee - 5
14. O - 3
15. Iguana - 3
16. Witherweaver - 3
17. Archetype - 3


The Hydra (Station One)
Jailkeeper {LaLight #6}
Godfather
 
The Arrow (Station Two)
Strongman (Others and SM only)
Gunsmith
 
The Swan (Station Three)
Masons (Town only) {Teproc #5} {IDontPlayThisGame #8} {WitherWeaver #16}
Bomb
 
The Flame (Station Four)
Role Cop
1-Shot Day Vigilante
 
The Pearl (Station Five)
Watcher <b>{SpaceAnemonie #3} {Roadrunner #7}
Investigation Immune
 
The Orchid (Station Six)
2-Shot Redirector gkrieg #11} {iguanaiguana #15}
Summon “Mother” (SM only)
 
The Staff (Station Seven)
Doctor
1-Shot Kill Proof
 
The Looking Glass (Station Eight)
Roleblocker
Bodyguard

The Tempest (Station Nine)
Poisoner {Datswan #1} {Galzria #4}
Ninja (Others and SM only)
 
The Lamp Post (Station Ten)
Double Shot Candidate Cop
Tracker {Eevee #13}
 
The Statue of Tawret
Protector of the Island {Qvist #12}
JOAT (1-shot Ninja, 1-shot Strongman, 1-shot Roleblocker)
 
The Bamboo Forest
Last Recruit {O #14}
Day 2 Innocent Child (Town only) {Jimmmmm #2}

The Cabin
1-Shot Disabler
Night 3 Forensic Scientist {Archetype #17}
 
The Dharma Initiative Barracks {2.7 #9} {faust #10}
Random - Investigation Immune
Random - Godfather
Random - JOAT


1. Datswan - You are Juliet Burke, the Others-aligned Poisoner. Your fake flavor claim is Mr. Eko. You are a Candidate.[/b]
2. Jimmmm - You are Aaron Littleton, the Crash Survivors-aligned Day 2 Innocent Child. Your fake flavor claim is Rose Nadler.
3. Space - You are Penelope Widmore, the Others-aligned Watcher. Your fake flavor claim is Ana-Lucia Cortez.
4. Galzria - You are Bernard Nadler, the Vanilla Crash Survivor. You are a Candidate.
5. Teproc - You are Sun Kwon, the Crash Survivors-aligned Mason. Your fake flavor claim is Claire Littleton. You are a Candidate.
6. Lalight - You are the Smoke Monster impersonating Sayid Jarrah, the Jailkeeper. Your fake flavor claim is Alex Rousseau.
7. Roadrunner - You are Nikki, the Vanilla Crash Survivor.
8. IDP - You are Charlie Pace, the Vanilla Crash Survivor.
9. 2.7 - You are Tom Friendly, the Crash Survivors-aligned Jack of all Trades. Your fake flavor claim is Frank Lapidus. You are a Candidate.
10. Faust - You are Walt Lloyd, the Others Goon.
11. Gkrieg - You are Daniel Faraday, the Crash Survivors-aligned 2-Shot Redirector. Your fake flavor claim is Libby.
12. Qvist - You are Hugo "Hurley" Reyes, the Protector of the Island. Your fake flavor claim is Cindy Chandler.
13. Eevee - You are Eloise Hawking, the Crash Survivors-aligned Tracker. Your fake flavor claim is Dr. Leslie Arzt. You are a Candidate.
14. O - You are Jin Kwon, the Crash Survivors-aligned Mason. Your fake flavor claim is Paolo.
15. Iguana - You are Naomi, the Others Goon. You are a Candidate.
16. Witherweaver - You are Shannon Rutherford, the Vanilla Crash Survivor.
17. Archetype - You are Miles Straume, the Crash Survivors-aligned Night 3 Forensic Scientist. Your fake claim is Michael Dawson.

[Teproc]

Right, so QT quoting.

Let's say you're scum, and you invent your little bit of N5 QT to convince me you're town. Now I ask you "ok, quote the rest. The whole thing. Oh, and by the way, faust should do that too".

Now, you'r eonline, so if you're scum and you don't have a whole QT you've been keeping as town the entire game, you're screwed.

faust/RR gets to write it, but it's gotta be very, very hard.

The rules are not a problem. All you say is "don't claim to quote from an outside source. You can still do vote counts, post counts, word documen,ts and actualm QT quoting, as long as you don't say that's what it is.

[Teproc]

Ah, I guess I should have gone Gunsmith. The thing is, I don't like being an investigative role, and Mason, while less powerful, just suits me better. As I said in my QT, I would have felt more comfortable being lower in bidding order really.

[Robz888]

Spectator QT: https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/eiwZ5AMuemNhU
Others QT: https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/aQ6H2MYMfNRLQ


NIGHT 1 ACTIONS
Eevee tracks 2.7: No Result
LaLight jails gkrieg
Lalight checks gkrieg: Not a Candidate
DatSwan poisons Jimmm, Jimmm is poisoned
DatSwan investigates Galzria: Not the Smoke Monster
SpaceAnemone watches faust: No Result
SpaceAnemone kills Witherweaver


NIGHT 2 ACTIONS
SpaceAnemone watches gkrieg, is redirected to watch Galz, result: "gkrieg13, iguanaiguana, Qvist"
DatSwan poisons chairs, chairs is poisoned
Iguana shoots Galzria, this fails because of protect candidates
gkrieg redirects gkrieg to Galzria
Qvist protects candidates (Galzria, iguana, DatSwan, Teproc, 2.7, Eevee)
Eevee tracks Qvist, result: "Galzria, iguana, DatSwan, Teproc, 2.7, Eevee"
Jimmmmm succumbs to poison

NIGHT 3 ACTIONS
SpaceAnemone watches Galzria, result: No Result
DatSwan kills gkrieg, gkrieg dies
DatSwan poisons 2.7, 2.7 is poisoned
chairs investigates Jimmmm, result: DatSwan
chairs succumbs to poison
Eevee tracks SpaceAnemone, result: Galzria

NIGHT 4 ACTIONS
Eevee tracks RoadRunner, result: No Result
DatSwan poisons O, O is poisoned
DatSwan kills Qvist, Qvist dies
2.7 succumbs to poison

NIGHT 5 ACTIONS
faust kills Eevee, Eevee dies
Eevee tracks Galzria, result: No Result
O succumbs to poison

[Galzria]

Ah, Faust DID go Barracks. Makes those two quotes make sense.

[Galzria]

e.... didn't block.

[Galzria]

Whoooo - Qvist, nice save on me!

[Teproc]

e.... didn't block.

What the ?

Blocking Swan would have almost won the game right there.

[Galzria]

Also, Gkrieg, your redirect from yourself to me N2 is interesting. Did you forsee me being protected in some way? Were you doing it as self-preservation? Or was there a different reason?

[chairs]

I wish I'd played. I would've gone for Flame, which nobody else did (at least as Town) - 1-shot dayvig yes pls.

[Robz888]

So! No one has gone for Doctor, or any Cop role, in any of these drafting games I've run (Mafia 100, Mafia 108 Original, and Mafia 108 Restart). That's something.

Town played great, obviously. Scum was also playing quite well until the pivotal Space lynch. LL, I'm honestly not sure what he did wrong Day 1, until his number mistake. Day 2 he made several errors.

I agree the Poisoner is too strong. I quite like the role, though. I came up with a nerf for it that I quite like: In the future, it will be 2-Shot, and a poisoned player will be informed the morning after they have been poisoned that "you are beginning to feel ill."

Teproc is MVP, for excellent play throughout, and making the correct call in the end. And it was a tough call, I think. I actually found the case against Galz quite persuasive. O is fully deserving of sharing credit here, he had terrific reads the whole game. If I could award co-MVPs, they would both get it. The Masons really won this game for town.

2.7 deserves a nod for spectacularly nailing DatSwan and faust dead to rights on the day Space got lynched, though his decision not to block DatSwan made the game no longer a guaranteed town win.

I also have to praise Qvist for his skillful and well-timed Protect Candidates play.

[Robz888]

e.... didn't block.

What the ?

Blocking Swan would have almost won the game right there.

Don't worry, we chewed him out in the speccy for that. 

[O]

woooooooooooooooooooo

Felt so good about the Space lynch -- until I learned that 2 of the other lynch candidates also were fine and "don't lynch Galzria" was the main requirement.

e thinking he'd survive a night was a pretty big mistake, but overall he (and the rest of town) played out LYLO quite well.

Still think poisoner is IMBA

[Galzria]

I wish I'd played. I would've gone for Flame, which nobody else did (at least as Town) - 1-shot dayvig yes pls.

That should've been my bid from draft 4. I probably would've A) been too scared to use it until this final day (when it wouldn't have mattered anyway), or b) used it D5 on Swan (when it wouldn't have mattered much anyway) - assuming I wasn't forced to use it D4 after mass-claiming (and on who? I don't even know how that plays out).