I feel like we are still talking ourselves in circles and not really getting anywhere.
I really don't like the case on rr. The point that was brought up about scum!runner kind of shutting down is interesting, but I don't find it convincing. I have already laid out my thoughts on the list.
I agree with what robz (or someone, not checking) said snit scum sitting back and letting town take the lead. Iguana has been in the front with his ideas and such. I have been more active today. Where is scum? Sitting back, commenting here and there, letting town argue with each other.
I think gkrieg's case built up while he was v/la and getting back he hasn't been able to build up a good defense like if he had been around more throughout. I think town!gkrieg gets that defense done.
J Reggie really just hasn't done much of anything. One more point to consider: scum don't want to lynch J Reggie. I spent a decent amount of time trying to build up a case against him, but the only other person in the game to vote for Reggie has been teproc earlier D1. Scum hasn't even been interested in using him as a potential "mislynch" and I think one reason is because he is scum. I think he makes more sense as mafia more then werewolf, so if we are just werewolf hunting (we aren't) then we don't have to lynch him.