I suspect anyone who is already pushing a lynch agenda. Scum already knows who they want to lynch, town has to figure it out. Throwing around claims of people being scum or town wily nilly is scummy.
Wait, what ? Why should we wait 24 hours or whatever before playing the game ? It's not like something is magically going to happen at one point... and the way you do figure things out is by voting. This is all mafia 101.
That's not what I mean. What I mean is that these posts:
yeah, ending up on faust was no good. Thanks for reminding me.
vote: J Reggie
I think the exact opposite of E.
I mean, clearly he's wrong. WW's shot TWM, who was very obviously townie. Most townie, in fact. So clearly they want to work with Mafia at least for a while.
Mafia clearly guessed (if you can call it that) right that WWs would shoot the townie.
I actually think this makes RR look like a Mafia who was added to the list with the expectation that very townie TWM or ig would get shot.
Vote: RR
Well, when I caught up I was pretty sure TWM was scum. So much for that. I guess I'll go back to vote: gkrieg with the intent to put together a good case tomorrow, when I'm more awake.
Hmm. Kind of surprised of the choices. As others have alluded to, Iguana and TWM were somewhat universally read as town, and my personal feeling of RR also being town makes it seem to me like mafia purposefully picked towny players for their list. Wouldn't mafia want to put their two WW-reads on the list? If they could keep the same guy on the list for multiple nights and they wouldn't die, I think it's a safe bet town would start to consider lynching them.
I think it's unlikely mafia put themselves on the list. FOS anyone not named!
vote: eevee
Actually, Vote: ashersky!! I just checked the player list, and I legitimately didn't remember he was in this game! That's so very unlike him.
feel like they are pushing some sort of agenda, not analyzing the game. They read like they've already solved the game, which is scummy. Contrary to that, some of e's other posts, Joseph's posts, and Teproc's posts are giving a solvy/towny feel.
My perspective was probably influenced by two things. One, I was wrong about two strong scumreads - TWM and Faust. Two, I paid no attention to this game at all during night-phase because I felt 65% confident I'd be dead and it wouldn't matter to analyze the game. Those both make me feel like I need to re-evaluate and I guess I was also putting that on other people.
That being said, I still think scum plays cocky today knowing that nontown factions make up almost 50% of the game. They go out and start trying to steer the conversation. So yeah, Gkrieg, Eevee, and maybe Robz, e and J Reggie look scummy.
I also totally suspect Teproc of faking all this game-solvy-ness but there's no way we lynch him today after mislynching Faust yesterday. I'd say same probably goes for e.
Eevee seems like the best lynch to me right now but I still haven't reread D1.
Author
Topic: M103: fleetwood mac (that's all for everyone) (Read 159954 times)