Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[liopoil]

Hi guys! If anything urgent is happening, let me know, otherwise I will start way back at day 1.

[Witherweaver]

Yes, there is urgent:

1) Are you scum?
2) You should have some special cards, like Swamp Hag, and uh.. well, I guess we need to think about whether or not you should say if it was used last night.  Okay, maybe you have to go read. 

[liopoil]

1) Are you scum?
2) You should have some special cards, like Swamp Hag, and uh.. well, I guess we need to think about whether or not you should say if it was used last night.  Okay, maybe you have to go read. 

1) Nope!
2) Maaaayyyyybe.

[liopoil]

No, I did not read every single post, but I skimmed everything and got the general gist.

Day 1: Lots of waffling around by everybody, almost nobody with strong reads. Then deadline came so we lynched Awaclus, okay.
Day 2: I really agree with almost everything Ichi says here. There's some stuff with Dominion cards going on too and extra days, maybe I should read my QTs. Oh hey, I claimed:

Does Pit want to claim?

I think i have to claim at this point: I'm a VT, but i got Swamp Hag.

If you don't believe me, you can still lynch me tomorrow, without losing much (slightly less information for the lynch today compared to the one that would happen tomorrow + me possibly being a scum PR with a night activated power), while gaining the no-kill / hated for scum.

Interesting.

Then LA literally claimed scum so we lynched him. Also woah, Silverspawn has been buddying me so hard the whole game, suspicious, since I'm a newbie. Oh wait he got NKed and flipped town, fine. Seprix has also been all over the place without pushing anything too hard, which in general I think is a scummy thing.

Day 3: Hey that's now. Not much has happened. Okay, now I'll figure out role stuff.

So, right now I have a slight townread on Ichimaru Gin, slight scumread on Seprix. But really, time to figure out the role madness.

[liopoil]

2) You should have some special cards, like Swamp Hag, and uh.. well, I guess we need to think about whether or not you should say if it was used last night.  Okay, maybe you have to go read. 

I don't see any reason for me not to say this. If I did use it, we should be checking everyone for sure. If I didn't use it, oh well. I won't claim it yet just to give anyone a chance to tell me not to. I can confirm that I do/did have the Swamp Hag.

[Witherweaver]

Well obviously, you'd have a real hard time convincing everyone that you subbed into lying!town.

[liopoil]

Well obviously, you'd have a real hard time convincing everyone that you subbed into lying!town.

Of course, but it can't hurt just to verify that I'm on the same page as pit was. People have made mistakes, you know.

[Ichimaru Gin]

Well, if Grey doesn't show up soon, I have some stuff to claim.

[Ichimaru Gin]

Also, could we get a vote count for today. I don't know how many people are alive!

[faust]

Hi lio! Man, it's been a while since I've been in a game with you... I feel like the last one was Dice Mafia.

Anyway, does anyone besides me have reads?

[liopoil]

Hi lio! Man, it's been a while since I've been in a game with you... I feel like the last one was Dice Mafia.

Anyway, does anyone besides me have reads?

The last one was Dice Mafia. That was the most recent non-Blitz non-Bastard game I've played.

Also, could we get a vote count for today. I don't know how many people are alive!

Pretty sure 7 people are alive.

[faust]

Not Voting: GreyICE, Pit, faust, Witherweaver, Ichimaru Gin, Hydrad, Seprix

[faust]

Hydrad reread.

He starts out voting for Library because he's new. The fact that he didn't pick Grey is minimally scummy. He says he'll treat Jimmmmm as an IC. He sheeps silver's vote on WW, and then swithces to silver. He has LA in his won't lynch list due to policy. Starts D2 saying he wants to look at LA and Seprix, and continues to vote LA. Has town reads on WW and Ichi. He says LA has felt pretty scummy to him D1 (something he never stated D1).

Eh. So Hydrad's treatment of LA could easily be a bus. He calls him scummy basically without any reason at all, and always keeps a second choice. And if Hydrad is scum, I think chances are the second scum is WW or Ichi.

[faust]

Vote: Hydrad to get things started.

[Witherweaver]

Hydrad reread.

He starts out voting for Library because he's new. The fact that he didn't pick Grey is minimally scummy. He says he'll treat Jimmmmm as an IC. He sheeps silver's vote on WW, and then swithces to silver. He has LA in his won't lynch list due to policy. Starts D2 saying he wants to look at LA and Seprix, and continues to vote LA. Has town reads on WW and Ichi. He says LA has felt pretty scummy to him D1 (something he never stated D1).

Eh. So Hydrad's treatment of LA could easily be a bus. He calls him scummy basically without any reason at all, and always keeps a second choice. And if Hydrad is scum, I think chances are the second scum is WW or Ichi.

I like the case on Hydrad, the thing with specifically pointing out (multiple times) of not lynching LA because of policy is suspicious.  I don't really see Ichi.  I'm obviously town.

Vote: Hydrad

[faust]

Hydrad reread.

He starts out voting for Library because he's new. The fact that he didn't pick Grey is minimally scummy. He says he'll treat Jimmmmm as an IC. He sheeps silver's vote on WW, and then swithces to silver. He has LA in his won't lynch list due to policy. Starts D2 saying he wants to look at LA and Seprix, and continues to vote LA. Has town reads on WW and Ichi. He says LA has felt pretty scummy to him D1 (something he never stated D1).

Eh. So Hydrad's treatment of LA could easily be a bus. He calls him scummy basically without any reason at all, and always keeps a second choice. And if Hydrad is scum, I think chances are the second scum is WW or Ichi.

I like the case on Hydrad, the thing with specifically pointing out (multiple times) of not lynching LA because of policy is suspicious.  I don't really see Ichi.  I'm obviously town.

Vote: Hydrad

Well, I think of you and Ichi as likely partners mostly due to PoE. I don't quite see Hydrad suspecting both his teammates D2, so that eliminates Seprix. And Grey and pit/lio are likely town.

[Ichimaru Gin]

Ok. Time to claim.

I received the Storyteller last night (a power that we picked in our qt). It allowed me to pick any player, and if they were town, they would become loved. I picked GreyICE.

So. We need 4 votes on GreyICE, and no more than four! And then, he will either flip scum or become an IC. Unless there is some other mechanic that intereferes with it, which I think is pretty unlikely.

[Ichimaru Gin]

Also. I will request a prod on GreyICE

[Ichimaru Gin]

Is there any reason not to suspect faust? I should probably reread. iirc he was on the LA wagon.

[faust]

I confirm that power.

Interesting. What if Ichi is scum? Then he either tells the truth or wants to bring in another mislynch, at the cost of his death. Being able to take down one of the towniest players to reach LyLo is not the worst thing ever. If we lynch Ichi, and he flips town, we enter tomorrow with 2/5 scum, and it would take 4 to lynch town!Grey. So if we pick one townie correctly, we could still confirm Grey... or we hope to catch scum and then Grey can't die the following Day.

How do you guys stand on testing Grey? I think he's rather townie, so I would prefer not to. Ichi, why do you think we need to test?

Anyway, if we do decide to test, I think the best strategy is for Grey to pick 4 players to vote for him.

[faust]

Is there any reason not to suspect faust? I should probably reread. iirc he was on the LA wagon.

There's a reason not to suspect me: I'm town.

[faust]

Basically, I think we should test Grey if and only if we would lynch him. I don't consider that, so I don't want to test.

[Ichimaru Gin]

Basically, I think we should test Grey if and only if we would lynch him. I don't consider that, so I don't want to test.

Why? That makes no sense at all.

Unless there's a danger of scum quicklynching him and that costing us the game, this is absolutely what we are going to do. Yeah, I'm calling a faust/GreyICE for the rest of the scumteam. You're not making any sense, and you saying you're town doesn't convince me either.

vote: GreyICE

3 more votes please. No more. No less.

[Ichimaru Gin]

I confirm that power.

Interesting. What if Ichi is scum? Then he either tells the truth or wants to bring in another mislynch, at the cost of his death. Being able to take down one of the towniest players to reach LyLo is not the worst thing ever. If we lynch Ichi, and he flips town, we enter tomorrow with 2/5 scum, and it would take 4 to lynch town!Grey. So if we pick one townie correctly, we could still confirm Grey... or we hope to catch scum and then Grey can't die the following Day.

How do you guys stand on testing Grey? I think he's rather townie, so I would prefer not to. Ichi, why do you think we need to test?



Anyway, if we do decide to test, I think the best strategy is for Grey to pick 4 players to vote for him.

I missed this. I would be fine with that plan, except you're the one to suggest it. If scum as some way of interfering with this, you just gave scum Grey a way to save himself. Let's pick the players who will vote for him randomly. I'll even unvote for now.

But seriously, how is Grey one of the towniest players? I don't even care. After this, he'll be an IC--or dead scum.

[Witherweaver]

I don't Faust's argument.  I don't see Grey as being any more likely town than Ichi is, and as Grey is a complete unknown, this is a good thing. 

What's the advantage of having Grey pick the people to vote for him?