I was curious about who voted for whom and why. I went through and compiled the votes from day 1. A number is attached to each vote indicating which vote number it is for that target, e.g. Bob (3) means this is the third vote for Bob. A number is also attached to each unvote, indicating the number of votes remaining AFTER the unvote, so if "Bob unvotes Joe (2)" that means that there are still 2 votes left on Joe, not counting Bob.
Please let me know if I missed anything or got anything wrong. Here it is in chronological order. I'm going to pull this out by person and put that in a different post.
Page 8
191: CFrisk votes for Galzria (1), citing high post count.
192: Eevee votes for yuma (1), citing low post count.
195: michaeljb votes for yuma (2), saying he wants to generate talk.
Page 9
207: O votes for Morgrim (1) by random chance.
210: michaeljb unvotes yuma (1) after yuma responds.
Page 10
229: Eevee unvotes yuma (0). No longer finds yuma suspicious.
Page 11
251: CFrisk unvotes Galzria (0) and votes for Morgrim (2), partially agreeing with O's randomness but also because Morgrim's posts have been suspicious unsubstantial, as if wanting to maintain appearance of activity.
254: Morgrim randomly votes for def (1), though randomness is not verifiable. He says he felt pressured to vote because there were already 2 votes on him (in #261).
263: yuma votes for Morgrim (3) in response to his odd behaviour and CFrisk's arguments.
Page 12
275: Morgrim unvotes def (0), now convinced that random voting is bad town play.
285: jotheonah votes for O (1) because O is OK with random lynch and has been "getting annoying".
297: Morgrim votes for O (2) because he continues to support random voting.
299: Galzria votes for O (3) because he is "being purposefully unhelpful and blind to simple logic and reasoning".
Page 13
310: jotheonah unvotes O (2), saying he doesn't want to leave his vote on O overnight.
314: CFrisk unvotes Morgrim (2); now considers that Morgrim is more unorthodox than scummy.
321: Galzria unvotes O (1) as O now appears to be helpful.
Page 14
332: CFrisk votes for jotheonah (1) because he had been "ok with killing a bad townie".
341: Dsell votes for Robz (1) because he has been playing the middle ground, the very thing Robz had warned of.
Page 15
354: eHalcyon votes for O (4) because he said he would have self-hammered.
Page 16
393: CFrisk unvotes jotheonah (0) and votes for Robz (2), saying that he had been "hiding from this game" and seemed opposed to casting votes and moving forward.
397: Morgrim unvotes O (1) because he will be absent in the next few days.
Page 19
452: O unvotes and votes for Eevee (1) , apparently because Eevee insulted him.
456: eHalcyon unvotes O (0) after O explains his self-lynch idea.
457: Galzria votes for jotheonah (1) and actually does give many reasons for it, but many of these are discarded as weak or else somehow forgotten.
458: Eevee votes for Robz (3) following Dsell's analysis that his activity seems similar to Mafia II.
471: Robz votes for Eevee (2) after voicing high suspicion of Eevee and Dsell and choosing Eevee since he already had a vote on him.
Page 20
493: jotheonah votes for def (1), saying that the mafia are probably among those who have not voted and are angling for no lynch.
Page 21
502: yuma unvotes Morgrim (0) and votes for jotheonah (2) due to his extreme defensiveness against Galzria's vote and his apparently deflective vote on def.
503: michaeljb votes for jotheonah (3) based on on-going discussion and analysis.
523: Voltgloss votes for Robz (4) with a pretty strong case in that post. Later reveals that this was an "experiment".
Page 22
532: jotheonah unvotes for def (0) and votes for Robz (5) because the existing case is strong and Robz is unconvincing.
Page 23
569: Voltgloss votes for jotheonah (4) due to the results of an "experiment" (described in #575). This implicitly unvotes Robz (4).
Page 24
582: Morgrim votes for jotheonah (5) based on the existing case.
597: Voltgloss unvotes jotheonah (4) after his role claim, so that he can speak the next morning.
Page 26
625: Galzria unvotes jotheonah (3) because jo probably won't be lynched after his role claim.
648: Galzria votes for jotheonah (4) again, at Voltgloss' request.
649: Voltgloss votes for jotheonah (5) again, after Galzria revotes.
Page 28
676: jotheonah unvotes Robz (3) and votes for Eevee (3) due to O's suggestion for surviving.
698: Voltgloss unvotes jotheonah (4) after jotheonah's specific role claim -- he can be investigated in the night.
Page 29
706: michaeljb unvotes jotheonah (3) following his role claim.
Page 30
728: Galzria unvotes jotheonah (2) and votes for Robz (4) due to Dsell's persuasion that he may have read Robz wrong.
744: eHalcyon votes for Galzria (1) due to increasingly odd behaviour, suddenly turning on Robz.
Page 31
762: O unvotes Eevee (2) and votes for Galzria (2) after Galzria says it is better to mislynch than no lynch.
764: jotheonah unvotes Eevee (1) and votes for Galzria (3) with a relatively long post about how he became more suspicious.
765: Galzria unvotes Robz (3) and votes for himself (4).
Page 32
776: Eevee votes for Galzria (5) for the same reason as O, thus implicitly unvoting Robz (2).
783: CFrisk unvotes Robz (1) and votes for Galzria (6) on the basis of his self-vote.
788: Galzria unvotes himself (5) due to comments against self-lynching.
791: Galzria votes for jotheonah (3) once more.
Page 33
823: Dsell votes for Galzria (6) after a lot of hedging kind of talk. This implicitly unvotes Robz (0).
Page 34
844: Morgrim votes for Galzria (7) even though he says he thinks Galz is town. This implicitly unvotes jotheonah (2).