I think the "BA is scum that rolled 1 die, has the reroll power, but can't reroll himself" is an awfully interesting line of thought. I'm certainly less inclined than others (Voltaire) to just right anybody off as town just yet.
Point of clarification, D1 POE isn't an attempt to "name the scum team D1", it's an attempt to "maximize the odds the D1 lynch is on scum". There's really only one person I'm "writing off" as town right now and it's XP. Though I certainly think several others are town right now.
Well, if you're town, how do you feel about being found scummy for playing a low dice?
What does it make you think of faust that he's handing out scum points right and left for things which are random and out of our control to a large degree? I mean, unless you roll a ton of dice, you aren't guaranteed to get a large number.
See the problem with your defense, as I said before, is that you're not really defending against the other person's position. If someone is finding you scummy for having a low roll, they obviously don't think that you're town and just got unlucky. Yes, it's possible it's random and out of your control, but it may also not be out of your control. It's also possible that a low roll is from a scum who rolled multiple dice, saved a different one, and played a low or mid-range roll in hopes we'd miss out on killing the monster.
If you're telling the truth here, then yes, from your position it was just random and unlucky. Form everyone else's position, they can't know that. The claim that Faust targeted you unfairly isn't really valid; you have to see the line of thinking where playing low rolls draws suspicion.