Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

Scum team is shraeye/EFHW/mail-mi by the way. You're welcome.

To what extent do you feel it's possible for each of these three players to be Survivor/SK/Other!Baddie, rather than working in concert as a faction?

Uh I don't really know. These reads are partially informed by EFHW/mail-mi's attitude towards shraeye though, in that sense they're more likely to be partners. I don't think there would necessarily be a Survivor in this, and we have no evidence of extra Nightkill other than the ones that cayvie claimed, so I wouldn't assume an SK here.

All of them I think also work as Galzria's partners I think, but I'd have to go back and check.

[EFHW]

Here's a new twist,  contradicting everything I've said so far (of course). What if faust is Shraeye's enemy? He suspects me for being on Shraeye's wagon even though he is there, too. Don't know how mail-mi fits in there; he isn't voting Shraeye.

[faust]

Here's a new twist,  contradicting everything I've said so far (of course). What if faust is Shraeye's enemy? He suspects me for being on Shraeye's wagon even though he is there, too. Don't know how mail-mi fits in there; he isn't voting Shraeye.

If I was his enemy, then why would he say that I'm town, and why hasn't he shot me already?

It's also the most reductive thing ever to assume that the only reason I have for suspecting people is whether they are voting for a particular person at a given moment.

[EFHW]

It was a theory, not a pronouncement. Maybe you get to have a qt with your target. That would very ash.

[EFHW]

Before you tear it apart, yes there are holes in the theory. But it's interesting to think about.

[EFHW]

The green text in particular is a problem in the narrative.  Shraeye's enemy sounds like a one person assassin faction, not town aligned. Maybe also a survivor,  but only one of them can win. "This town isn't big enough for the two of us."

So, it would be great if Shraeye could answer my questions and make himself more believable.

[EFHW]

Shraeye could be the enemy looking for his target, also unknown to him. His having a killing power doesn't make him different from his enemy. More likely that they are both nefarious than that he is defending himself.

But then are they threats to town? Maybe not.

[EFHW]

@Shraeye,  how has your situation influenced your voting?

[faust]

So, it would be great if Shraeye could answer my questions and make himself more believable.

Maybe, but I get a feeling that shraeye will be busy with other things these next couple of days.

[Swowl]

Shraeye - I am being dumb and cannot find it. What is your actual win con?

[Swowl]

It was a theory, not a pronouncement. Maybe you get to have a qt with your target. That would very ash.

wait I don't get this with your previous statement about Shraeye being the baddie. Didn't faust claim to be the one doing the targeting of the QT opened up?

[EFHW]

It was a theory, not a pronouncement. Maybe you get to have a qt with your target. That would very ash.

wait I don't get this with your previous statement about Shraeye being the baddie. Didn't faust claim to be the one doing the targeting of the QT opened up?

I'm entertaining several scenarios.  They aren't necessarily consistent.

[Swowl]

It was a theory, not a pronouncement. Maybe you get to have a qt with your target. That would very ash.

wait I don't get this with your previous statement about Shraeye being the baddie. Didn't faust claim to be the one doing the targeting of the QT opened up?

I'm entertaining several scenarios.  They aren't necessarily consistent.

fair enough. just like, when you say "get a QT with your target" what do you mean? cuz they are both alive and we had two deaths. So like if the target is a kill target, that is kind of unlikely.

[skip wooznum]

vote: shraeye

I thought shraeye would say stuff and I would read them. No real reason to wait around.

[Swowl]

that is L-1 on Shraeye by the way...

[Swowl]

I am not sure what the rules are here on what I am allowed to say in the game... but we should uhm... allow shraeye a small amount of time to check in if it is answers to questions that you want.

[skip wooznum]

Oh, I thought he wasn't going to make it back before deadline.

unvote I guess...

[ashersky]

Vote Count: 3.4

EFHW (2): uncle, DatSwan
shraeye (3): faust, EFHW, 2.7
uncle (1): mail-mi


Not Voting (3): SpaceAnemone, shraeye, skip

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Day 3 ends at 20:00 on May 1 forum time.

[mail-mi]

[quote from Eddie]Back to you, though, do you have any strong reads? Most of your reads are coupled with a disclaimer at the end which waters them down a touch more than the post would suggest

I really agree with this. mail-mi has been hedging all game. And the Eddie/me partner theory has no substance to it.

I think Eddie is probably town,  unfortunately.
[/quote]

That is blatantly false, I was confident on both my Faust and MiX reads. What you may see as hedging is me not quite trusting my own reads because so far they've been bad.

[EFHW]

It was a theory, not a pronouncement. Maybe you get to have a qt with your target. That would very ash.

wait I don't get this with your previous statement about Shraeye being the baddie. Didn't faust claim to be the one doing the targeting of the QT opened up?

I'm entertaining several scenarios.  They aren't necessarily consistent.

fair enough. just like, when you say "get a QT with your target" what do you mean? cuz they are both alive and we had two deaths. So like if the target is a kill target, that is kind of unlikely.

I don't know. It sounds like a pretty intense relationship. Maybe they can talk it out?

[EFHW]

[quote from Eddie]Back to you, though, do you have any strong reads? Most of your reads are coupled with a disclaimer at the end which waters them down a touch more than the post would suggest

I really agree with this. mail-mi has been hedging all game. And the Eddie/me partner theory has no substance to it.

I think Eddie is probably town,  unfortunately.

That is blatantly false, I was confident on both my Faust and MiX reads. What you may see as hedging is me not quite trusting my own reads because so far they've been bad.
[/quote]
I didn't say you hedged everything, just that it occurred multiple times. I'll dig up quotes tomorrow.

[EFHW]

I am not sure what the rules are here on what I am allowed to say in the game... but we should uhm... allow shraeye a small amount of time to check in if it is answers to questions that you want.

rules??

[shraeye]

So, it would be great if Shraeye could answer my questions and make himself more believable.

I was under the impression that I went through all most recent posts and answered everything in my big ol post earlier.  Please quote/repeat your question and ill get to it.

Settle your pants down, skip. You were honestly worried o wouldn't make it back before a deadline that is 6 days from now??

But also, we just had second kid today, so give me amoment, yeah?

[shraeye]

@Shraeye,  how has your situation influenced your voting?

Please clarify, thanks

[shraeye]

vote: shraeye

I thought shraeye would say stuff and I would read them. No real reason to wait around.

What stuff are you waiting for?