I mean, I'm fine with putting myself out of the lynch pool for obvious reasons, but I don't think we should take manda out. If anything, that's just encouraging her not to post. I also don't really know where the town read everyone seems to have on her is coming from.
Voltaire reread.
#230 Questions ash's justification for his lack of a plan.
#250 Post about the Jimmmm/Robz thing early on, but what's interesting to me is that he changes his mind in the middle of the post, which I think is something that town does a lot more than scum.
#315 Joins Jorbles in defending me after mcmc voted for me.
#334 Votes for ash for being too much in the background / not having a plan. Ash had no votes at that point.
#356 Starts PoE, crosses manda and Morgrm off his lynch pool.
#576 Catch_up post. Buddies me in a similar way he did in GoT, still finds ash scummy (but mentions that super scummy ash always turns out to be town), likes the "random lurker" Jorbles lynch.
#592 PoE. Crossed me in a previous post for being easier to read later, and 2.7 for his claim.
#624 Doesn't see the Walrus case (made by ash)
#648 Discourages a Tracker to counterclaim Morgrim.
#688 Comes out strongly against a Morgrim lynch, saying it "almost never makes sense to lynch a claimed PR"
#755 Changes his mind, sees the usefulness in Morgrim's flip, and says he's more likely to flip scum than not. Lynch pool is otherwise the same as before.
#766 Clarifies why he thinks a Mogrim lynch makes life easier for PRs : they don't have to target Morgrim anymore.
#799 Hammers Morgrim.
Day 2
#926 Catch up post. Finds ash scummy but says he could also be town tunneling. Votes Jimmmm for his attitude at the end of day 1, following Robz's reasoning.
#946 Unvotes Jimmmmm after finding out that he had misremembered one of his posts day 1.
#947 Crazy PoE. Crosses off Robz and manda for misreading the setup, 2.7 presumably for the claim, and ash for unclear reasons.
#958 Votes Walrus, sheeping mcmc.
#1110 Defends his Morgrim hammer by saying even if Morgrim was a PR there was no way of knowing he would use it in a way beneficial to town, and saying he was faking his own meta.
#1163 After Jimmmmm claimed, says we should lynch Jimmmm first because RB is more valuable than Goon Cop. Later votes for Jimmmmm, then unvotes when Walrus counterclaims ash.
#1205 Orders the non-claiming people from least to most scummy :
Robz
manda
Teproc
mcmc
Day 3 : not much actually, mostly defending himself against Robz and referring to Eevee's case against him in GoT again.
Ok, so the interactions with ash are puzzling here. He was voting for ash for most of D1 and constantly talks about how scummy ash is. There's a turn in day 2 (the Jimmmmm/ash fight) where he starts believing ash is town, enough to take him out of his lynch pool (!), and enough to make him want to lynch Jimmmmm before ash after Jimmmmm's claim. Rereading, I think I understand his case here better. It's just that he had a scum read on Jimmmmmm before the claim (because of the end of day 1), but believed ash to be town, so he wanted to lynch his scumread first. By the way, the Roleblocker being more valuable is true, but less important than scumreads at this point, which is why I disagreed and went for ash (I had a town read on Jimmmmm).
All of this to say: his attitude day 2 makes sense as town. It also makes sense as ash's scumpartner of course, since he would want to lynch Jimmmmm first then as well.
Basically these interactions are giving me nothing me more than a null read. The rest is comforting me in my town read. The way his opinion fluctuates within a post seems natural to me, and more likely to be done by town, he discourages any Tracker to counterclaim Morgrim, which scum would have loved to see (assuming they did recruit). The Morgrim hammer after coming out strongly against his lynch also seems a little too dangerous for scum to make in my eyes. I don't buy the "he's not incredibly useful and active so he's scum" argument. It was indeed made in GoT and just seems like a generally flimsy meta-argument.
Author
Topic: Mafia XXXV: Mafia and the Chocolate Factory (Game Over, Mafia Wins!) (Read 170312 times)