Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

In fact, let me make this statement:

scum!scott would not have killed yuma.

People voting for scott, please refute this.

[Witherweaver]

On D3, he gets in when gkrieg is at L-1 and is suspicious of that wagon. I don't know. It's certainly a thing to try and get something onto WW as scum, but at that point it seems really difficult to do that. And scum!scott would 100% have had all the things figured out when they killed yuma. So what does that leave me with...? scum!scott means that scum knew that killing yuma would make gkrieg look very bad. If they went through with it anyway, I would assume that they push that lynch hard. scott didn't do that. In the end, this means a town read.

You mean, like you did?

[faust]

On D3, he gets in when gkrieg is at L-1 and is suspicious of that wagon. I don't know. It's certainly a thing to try and get something onto WW as scum, but at that point it seems really difficult to do that. And scum!scott would 100% have had all the things figured out when they killed yuma. So what does that leave me with...? scum!scott means that scum knew that killing yuma would make gkrieg look very bad. If they went through with it anyway, I would assume that they push that lynch hard. scott didn't do that. In the end, this means a town read.

You mean, like you did?

Yes. And like Teproc did.

[silverspawn]

scum!scott would not have killed yuma.

Mhpf. I agree.

He was not alone though. But yeah meh. unvote

[scott_pilgrim]

Catching up now

[scott_pilgrim]

scum!scott would not have killed yuma.

Well I know I'm biased but I think this is actually a really good point.

[Witherweaver]

scum!scott would not have killed yuma.

Well I know I'm biased but I think this is actually a really good point.

Why, what would you have done?

[scott_pilgrim]

I'm a little wary of faust because I feel like he's agreed with me on basically everything this game.  At first I thought Teproc's case on him looked really solid, but then faust's defense looked really solid too.  My gut says one of {faust, Teproc} is scum, and I think it's more likely Teproc, but at this point I'm worried that it's just a bias that I'm carrying over from earlier in the game.  Otherwise, there's:

EgorK - town
Hydrad - null
Witherweaver - null
silverspawn - scum

I still think silverspawn is the best lynch just based on D3.  But that's just based on my memory of it, I want to go back and reread silverspawn at some point, maybe later tonight.

[scott_pilgrim]

scum!scott would not have killed yuma.

Well I know I'm biased but I think this is actually a really good point.

Why, what would you have done?

I don't know...not go after a likely doc target?

[scott_pilgrim]

Although I guess to be fair, I don't really see any of the currently alive players doing that...

[Witherweaver]

scum!scott would not have killed yuma.

Well I know I'm biased but I think this is actually a really good point.

Why, what would you have done?

I don't know...not go after a likely doc target?

Er.. why?

[scott_pilgrim]

I'm a little wary of faust because I feel like he's agreed with me on basically everything this game.  At first I thought Teproc's case on him looked really solid, but then faust's defense looked really solid too.  My gut says one of {faust, Teproc} is scum, and I think it's more likely Teproc, but at this point I'm worried that it's just a bias that I'm carrying over from earlier in the game.

Actually...I feel like this whole game I've mentally just given faust a pass because he's agree with me on everything and assumed Teproc is scum because he disagrees with me on everything.  Now I'm super worried this whole time scum!faust has been doing this to get me on his side.

[scott_pilgrim]

scum!scott would not have killed yuma.

Well I know I'm biased but I think this is actually a really good point.

Why, what would you have done?

I don't know...not go after a likely doc target?

Er.. why?

So that my partner doesn't get lynched when the kill goes through?

[scott_pilgrim]

I'm a little wary of faust because I feel like he's agreed with me on basically everything this game.  At first I thought Teproc's case on him looked really solid, but then faust's defense looked really solid too.  My gut says one of {faust, Teproc} is scum, and I think it's more likely Teproc, but at this point I'm worried that it's just a bias that I'm carrying over from earlier in the game.

Actually...I feel like this whole game I've mentally just given faust a pass because he's agree with me on everything and assumed Teproc is scum because he disagrees with me on everything.  Now I'm super worried this whole time scum!faust has been doing this to get me on his side.

Although why does scum buddy me specifically, that seems like something people always bring up but in practice doesn't really happen.

[Witherweaver]

Well food for thought; you're scum!Doctor... do you bring up the idea of Doctoring your partner?

[Witherweaver]

Reasonable scenario is that Gkrieg (having just subbed in) didn't really look back at everything, thought Faust was townie (which, if Faust is town, one would exaggerate as scum since they know it to be true), and thought he was the most sensible Doctor target.  So Gkreig just did what he would think he would do as town.  Then partners thought it would be good to kill  Yuma.

[Witherweaver]

It's possible scum did not consider Yuma the 'obvious' choice for Doctor anyway; I didn't, after all. 

[silverspawn]

Wait. What are we even talking about? With scum in the doc neighborhood, mafia knew that yuma was not protected, so killing him was safe.

[Teproc]

Why is S_P less likely than anyone else to have killed yuma ? I truly don't follow...

[Teproc]

If the idea is that S_P would have realised it meant gkrieg's likely death, then you're basically arguing the scum team is Hydrad and.... maybe EgorK ? Really though Hydrad is about the only player who I could see not realising that, and even then I'm not so sure.

[silverspawn]

scott is more of a maths guy and is more likely to think of who is being protected

[Teproc]

Again, any team of two you can think of could've seen how killing yuma was going to put gkrieg in danger.

In fact I'd put S_P among the most likely to not think of that simply because he's had periods of inactivity, and if that happened during the night he might have not had the time to think about it that much.

I doubt this is faust's argument though.

[silverspawn]

Wait. What are we even talking about? With scum in the doc neighborhood, mafia knew that yuma was not protected, so killing him was safe.

the argument is invalid anyway.

[Teproc]

Wait, ok that argument makes even less sense than the one I thought I was responding to.

[silverspawn]

Wait, ok that argument makes even less sense than the one I thought I was responding to.

why