Ok ok. This doesnt have to be an argument thread (I'd rather it not be, since I was simply asking for feedback on a card), so I'll try to ease the tension a little.
As it is widely known, misinterpretation is very common when it comes to communication that is not face to face, or at least over the phone. Reading someone elses written words is wrought with peril as it is impossible to truly know with what inflection and tone the words were being thought/said. With that in mind, lets just say Warfreak was simply offering his take on the best wording, comparing it to official Dominion cards. Since he was the first responder, its quite clear he wasnt trying to tell anyone else that their suggestion is wrong.
I agree that the wording "on Dominion cards, its _____" does seem to be a definitive statement, but let's not jump on warfreak and assume he meant that no other wording is valid. One word like "most" or "some" in that statement would have completely changed this thread, I believe, and who's to say Warfreak wasn't thinking that originally?
Anyway, I think a few posts here have been taken as attacks when they likely were not meant as attacks, so if hopefully we can all just agree that both "name a card" and "choose a card" have been printed on official cards.
I would like some more feedback on the card itself though, is it priced fairly at $3? Should I limit the card chosen to $6 and drop the non-victory condition? Do you like it? Is it interesting? Obviously I think it is, but now that I'm happy with the wording, I'd appreciate some critiques of the mechanic and price.
Thanks!