And I just wanted to show a tigers power off by starting off powerful. I might raise the cost or make it +2 Cards instead. I’ll just wait and see what other people think of tiger before I change it.Just compare Tiger to Nobles, Destry, Josephine and Giant (there is a reason Giant only hits every other time) to realize how crazily overpowered it is.
I like the idea, but Lodge is the only of these that works well as a shelter IMO. You already said what's wrong with Acolyte's Abode, and Swamp Cabin seems pretty strong for a shelter. I guess it could be an interesting decision whether to keep it or not, but I think it potentially makes too much difference for a shelter.Good point, somebody with 4/3 being able to leech off somebody elses's 5/2 isn't a good idea.
That's not realistic by a long shot. Some of us do print fan cards but I never go so far as to make extra tokens (gotta print them, mount them on cardboard, cut them well) or whatever extra material the cards need but rather use what is available anyway.Well, the gentiles among us would have to use a D4 anyway.Not necessarily. In a “set” (probably a promo set) this would probably come with a Dreidel.
This is innovative, simple and plain brilliant.
Just a silly idea I've had kicking around for a while. Gamble on not all the Duchies getting bought, or some extra incentive to force a three-pile ending. (Or, even sillier, make last minute adjustments for Keep/Fairgrounds/etc.)
This is extremly Kingdom-dependent: nice with Villager-yielding Renaissance cards, otherwise strictly worse than Tunnel.QuotePaper MillNote that the first 3 Villagers are free, assuming you can't produce more.
Types: Victory
Cost: $3
Worth 1VP for every 2 tokens on your Villager mat more than the player who has the fewest tokens on their Villager mat (rounded down), but at least 1VP.
Setup: Each player gets +5 Villagers.
Bonkers with overdraw and the on-gain bonus is arguably too good relative to Acting Troupe.
Well, I can say that not once in my life have I bought Copper to get out of a bad situation.It is not something which occurs often in practice (Curser, Looter, no trasher is a situation which can become dire), but, well, there is a reason Coppers costs $0. As I said, it depends on whether you care about principles that only matter in very rare circumstances or not (I am nearly always leaning towards ignoring principles, rare edge cases and so on).
Anyway, a lot of what I was trying to say is about having 5 of them potentially being broken in not-that-rare kingdoms. Broken when you have a solid engine = broken.Yeah, I totally agree with that although I think that it has more to do with the pile control than the VPs.
The underdog player not having to lower piles was a thing I was meaning to talk about somewhere in there. And I do believe costing $1 is a form of synergy, as is being able to gain Lily by trashing Silver, as is being able to put Gilt back on top of the Lily remaining in the pile.$4s are never hard to get. I agree though that blocking the Lilies via Gilts returning to the pile is a nice feature.
I have no idea about what this is supposed to mean. Gilt trashes a card and (potentially) gains a card. It isn't, as you seem to imply, a net-gainer and thus doesn't contribute in this way as Lily fodder provider.Fine but then there is nothing special about Gilt being fed to Lily except for being cheap which only matters if Buys are cheap to come by.If there is a $2 Action in the kingdom and you spend $1 and 1 Buy getting a Gilt, you trash it twice before you have to buy another one, because you gain another card to trash. (And it used to be Estates, but I decided that was too nerfed with regard to the early game.)
It's worded how I mean it to be wordedFine but then there is nothing special about Gilt being fed to Lily except for being cheap which only matters if Buys are cheap to come by.
Gilt feeds you other stuff when trashed,If that is your intention, you have to word it differently. As it is currently worded it only trashes a Treasure at the end of the turn if it is in play, i.e. if you trash Gilt via another card like Lilies this Upgrade effect doesn't happen.
Note that there are only 3 Lillies, I think 5 is nuts. That's 5 VP a turn and, if you have an engine with some overdraw, milling 5 provinces off the supply if you've bought 1.Sure, the Transmogrify / Salt of Earth like pile control is nice but in order to pull that off you'd need to draw 10 cards: 5 Lilies and 5 cards you don't want anymore. And this or next turn you'd have to regain 5 cards to feed Lilies.
