The List:
(I’m fully aware these are almost useless. It’s mostly for me to keep track of how I’m feeling at certain points in the game, and to share that with all y’all.)
-----------------
People that are probably town:
Roadrunner: His post 390 just screams town to me. He’s trying to push the game as well, when scum are typically content to let sleeping dogs lie.
Yuma: The claim does a ton. This is so extremely dangerous to do as scum this early in the game. By no means does the claim mean he couldn’t be scum, but it’s just bad scum practice to do this right away. Maybe if the claim was a bomb or something, but it’s not. Additionally, most people seem to have accepted Yuma’s claim, and instead of just armchairing and popcorning, Yuma got into the thick of things, getting all debatey and stuff. This seems more town play to me.
-----------------
People that seem/feel town:
Awaclus: His entrance posts are goofy and carefree in the middle of an ongoing discussion. Scum often like to seem like they know what’s going on if entering the game later. However, you all said that he’s often random like this, so I’m taking it all with a grain of salt.
Iguanaiguana: Impassioned arguments about scum tells and early heavy arguments with SS reads pretty town to me. Ig’s a smart guy though, and could be trying some aggressive and dangerous play, but I’m not feeling it right now.
Silverspawn: Mostly same as Iguana. I normally look at early conflict and almost always town on town violence. I had Silver in the above category, but as the game went on, I realized that he very well could just be a hyperactive scum player. He seems like the type of guy that could do that, but for now I’m sticking with my initial analysis.
-----------------
Big ?s
2.7: Not a whole lot to go on here, and what I have seen hasn’t spoken to me either way. Concerning, but it’s early. We’ll see where things go from here. (Gosh I sound like a scum defending a partner by slight FoS but not really saying anything. Whatever, we’ll get more later.)
Faust: Initially faust came across very scummy, mostly just sitting there and throwing out peanut gallery comments here and there. However, he got very frustrated when people went after him aggressively, which tends to read town. However however, I think he’s smart enough to fake these types of emotions, though maybe not since last game he wanted to vote for PPS based on an out-of-game interaction. Gut says ?scum, head is confused.
Hydrad: Hydrad does what he wants. And I’ll be darned if I have any idea what that is.
Teproc: See, I said 50% chance of scum so I can do things like upgrade you to ?. On re-read, I don’t get as much of a scum feel from Teproc, and I find myself agreeing with a bunch of things he says. His recent list matches up a lot with what I’m putting here as well, things I was thinking before I saw his list. It will take a while for that initial scum feel to wear off, but we’ll leave Tep here for now.
Witherweaver: Wither I have no idea on. There’s definite possibility of being scum, as I think for the most part he’s been cruising with the crowd, but he’s had enough of a unique voice in discussions that I’m not sure what to think. Teh feelz aren’t much help either, as they’re all over the spectrum here. I’ll admit, I have no idea right now. Maybe another re-read???
-----------------
They could be scum?
EgorK: Chillin’ out maxin’ relaxin’ all cool. Maybe this is classic EgorK play but something feels off.
Haddock: Maybe it’s just the way he posts things, with lots of open-ended statements and questions and general uncertainty, but that type of posting is just really easy for scum to use and look like they’re doing something. I’ll probably be dead wrong on this one.