Okay so I'm now caught up on Day 3. There has been precious little scumhunting here. I'm going to read Day 1 and Day 2 maybe tonight or tomorrow, so if we could put off lynching me before then that would be lovely. Also I should be seeing Ash's role PM so it would be nice to wait for that since it'll either exonerate or condemn Ash now that he's claimed. If he's really a doctor with resurrecting powers, that's pretty definitely town IMO.
But I've got to go for the night soon, and Awaclus' claim doesn't make much sense to be. And he's either lying about his results or he was redirected somehow. I'd really prefer to lynch scum over myself, even if my lynching will be informative to town. It isn't equivalent though. If we lynch Awaclus and he flips scum rather than survivor, we know his results were fabricated rather than redirected, and we can just not bother lynching me. There is value to lynching scum first.
And that item makes 0 sense for a survivor to give away rather than claiming. If he claimed it and held onto it, that would make sure he wasn't NK'd which is excellent for a survivor. But that's not how he is playing. It makes a ton of sense for scum to give it away, hoping to reduce the number of town in the game. It also makes a lot of sense for a serial killer to just randomly sew chaos and reduce the player count.
Vote: Awaclus