If I didn't say enough in my qt, just wanted to reiterate how well I thought Haddock played this game. Was it really his first one?
Thanks Ichi. Yes it was my first game.
I screwed up though.
I was like 70% certain that if one of you/chairs was SK, it was you.
So I should have just hammered you. But I overthought it. I can't remember my exact thought processes, but it was something like:
If I hammer chairs and am wrong about it, the consequences are much less bad than if I hammer you and am wrong about it. My thinking was that it should have been fairly obvious to you (maybe it was, haven't read your QT yet) that I was scum, and as an NK-immune SK I thought it was to your advantage to hit town, since you were likely (at least I thought you were!) to lose a 2v1, whereas a 1v1v1 was winnable.
Anyway, well played, you did well to convince RR at the end there!