Okay I have made up my mind. I absolutely think we should lynch galz followed by Joseph.
First off robz and dsell are the two players who today have specifically been looking for both town and scum reads and looking for the two day big picture. Galz and Joseph have both pushed (galz soecifically) for a strong scum read based lynch today.
Galz I believe is aware I have been scum reading him and knows that the only way for him to win is to lynch Joseph today and then convince dsell to lynch robz tommorow.
Joseph has not had great analytical thoughts today at all. Mostly light retelling of wagons and very much misrepresented how gkrieg acted toward robz in day 2.
Moving on to how gkrieg acted day two as it is our best day for reads. Gkrieg made a large case/push for robz as the key “scum” player on the pps quicklynch. I felt this was very sumcunny and opportunistic and is what led me to nailing gkrieg as scum.
snip
Why is the vote opportunistic? I know I'm town, I am guessing that e is town. If Robz is town, then that means that he pushed for a quickhammer as town on town and then two town went and hammered PPS. That seems unlikely to me. You also say that Joseph's vote was good, but that his point was weak? How does sheeping a good vote make me opportunistic, and why is Joseph's point weak?
You said you agreed a lot with Joseph saying robz was scummy for pushing the quicklynch. Now you are claiming you find robz position on the wagon scummy which also makes very little sense.
Robz was the 4th in a wagon of 7. Sure conveniently you are the l-1 vote (you know the scummy one) and the 5th/7th votes are pseudo ic’s. I don’t think town!gkrieg think just because votes 5/6/7 are potentially all town that makes vote 4 scum over votes 2/3 (myself and Joseph, the person you are sheeping...). So your explanation actually reeks of scum justification saying “I know I’m town and that means this other player has to be scum”, when it really doesn’t mean that.
Oh, didn't realize Robz was the 4th on the wagon and not the 5th.
This is absolutely not the way a scum traitor makes a case on his partner. Not a chance.
Then proceeding through day two a few people hover on the robz wagon namely Joseph And hydrad who don’t like my gkrieg case. Galz is absent for the rest of the day never pushing the gkrieg or robz wagons ones that from his perspective are both possibly town.
Moving on to dsell we have to jump back to the beginning of day 2. Pre datswans cop reveal and launching into the robz/gkrieg wagons. We have an interesting interaction. Early on in the day lalight and DatSwan both pressure galzria. They find the way he handled day one scummy and start the wagon on him. (This wagon largely goes by he wayside later on as Joseph/gkrieg make a robz case and I make my gkrieg one). But right at that point we have this:
The other two ICs have their vote on Galzria. e, what do you think about that read?
I need to look back over the game with the new information. Looking at the 8 people in the lynchpool for today it is interesting that 4 were on wagon and 4 were off wagon D1. I lean toward at least one scum jumping on wagon yesterday, kind of think that may be a good place to start, and Galzria isn't there.
Dsell asking 2.7 how he feels about the galz wagon and 2.7 deflecting to look at other places. Why would scum!dsell as scum!e how he feels about this wagon in this way. This is very likely a towny question from dsell and a scummy pivot from 2.7 away from his partner.