Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[SpaceAnemone]

Wow, modkill sounds harsh, but I guess there's no way to tell what went on behind the scenes. Great boost for team town, though :-)

I was a Haddock's this evening and therefore off the forum, but I suddenly feel very motivated not to disappear for too long.

[silverspawn]

Wrong tree, silver.

schadd's font is red. Does that mean he was recruited?

what tree?

[EFHW]

Wrong tree, silver.

schadd's font is red. Does that mean he was recruited?

No? Why would you think that?

Just looking to get more info from the flip. I couldn't remember what color traitor usually is.

[EFHW]

Wrong tree, silver.

schadd's font is red. Does that mean he was recruited?

what tree?

English expression "barking up the wrong tree" means following an incorrect notion.

[Witherweaver]

Wrong tree, silver.

schadd's font is red. Does that mean he was recruited?

No? Why would you think that?

Just looking to get more info from the flip. I couldn't remember what color traitor usually is.

Same alignment and win con as Mafia team, so same color. They just aren't known by the Mafia team, and usually don't know the team as well.

[chairs]

Well then.

[Witherweaver]

I still like Haddock.

Could also do Space.

Not really sure how Mafia would react here. I would assume they didn't know Schadd was Mafia, but might have suspected. Probably best play would be to go after him regardless, as it's a reasonable argument even if he were town, but also might get towncred if he's scum.

Oh... maybe Mafia just shot him last night. There wasn't a traditional kill.

I guess that means Galzria doesn't get quite so much towncred for spearheading the Schadd thing.

Well, my original thought was if Mafia knew Schadd was with them, and they realized the hammer thing was a blunder, then it's likely at least one of them would want to get out ahead of it, so one of the people more eager to lynch Schadd is more likely scum.

Also, DatSwan looks seemingly better, because if Schadd ....... actually scratch that. I was going to say that DatSwan could have done all the town fakeclaims that fit in the scum QT, but Schadd would not have joined it until after night actions resolved, so they wouldn't have had time to talk about it.

Okay, so regardless no discussion between Schadd and Mafia team. I suppose I need to go back and look at whether the discussions around alignments of Priests look natural or premeditated.

[Witherweaver]

Haddock because the last post with the hedginess to vote Schadd looks partnerish.

[Witherweaver]

Darn.. my post just got eaten by a browser crash, and now I really need sleep :-(

Am likely to be in the same place as Haddock tomorrow night, so probably no forum time then..

Can you paraphrase what this post was going to be?

[iguanaiguana]

Vote: Haddock

[iguanaiguana]

silver chairs WE are towny. Maybe others. Not too sure who else is scum.

Is anyone else prodable? Dylan?

[iguanaiguana]

WE = WW

Bad autocorrect

[EFHW]

I was just looking at Flash. Was there anyone with the power to unfreeze someone? I'm thinking if ashersky is thawed he would be almost IC.

[EFHW]

It looks like the baseball bat could thaw him.

[silverspawn]

Why haddock?

[SpaceAnemone]

Darn.. my post just got eaten by a browser crash, and now I really need sleep :-(

Am likely to be in the same place as Haddock tomorrow night, so probably no forum time then..

Can you paraphrase what this post was going to be?

It was a messy post because I wasn't sure how much I wanted to say. But there's an answer in my QT that faust gave me during the item-bidding phase of the game that appears to directly contradict something Galz has said. Interestingly, faust himself ruled one way and then the other over the course of our little conversation in the QT. So I thought that one quite plausible explanation was that faust changed a mechanism from his original thinking. I assume he would have been careful to consider that mechanic's effects on current roles, but it would have been a whole extra effort to consider its interaction with all the possible fake-claim roles he must have had to come up with. That felt like weak evidence for Galz to be using a fake-claim, which was why I came out on the side of him maybe not being the townie one of the pair at first. There's also the possibility that Galz embellished or hybridized other fake-claim information, but I think scum!Galz would be more cautious, so I have to assume that most of this is mod-provided.

I've since asked faust a bit more in my QT, and he's basically agreed that what he said is correct in terms of game mechanics, but that if there are role mechanics that make things behave differently, he clearly would not have told me about their existence. I should expect nothing less from a mod whose interest is in keeping the game fair and balanced, even if I'd actually caught onto something. However, I'm kind of accepting that my initial confidence about there being something serious up with Galz's claim is probably unfounded.

[Awaclus]

I need to catch up on things.

[Haddock]

Haddock because the last post with the hedginess to vote Schadd looks partnerish.

Huh? Schadd was a traitor. No reason to expect scum know who he is.
Also I didn't hedge on schadd. Read again. I was very much of the opinion that he was town. I was willing to lynch him out of necessity, but that was it.

Vote: Haddock

Not this again. Can people who are voting me PLEASE reread? I haven't seen anything resembling a case. I'm town. I feel like I've played a towny game. 
I can't believe I'm being seen as more lynchable than swan.

silver chairs WE are towny. Maybe others. Not too sure who else is scum.

Is anyone else prodable? Dylan?

Don't think chairs or WW are towny. Null at best.
I still get bad feels about WW but it's just gut.

Dylan is lynchable. I'd go there.

[iguanaiguana]

Dylan is not lynchable. He's lurking. 2 towny posts from him.

Request prod on Dylan

[Witherweaver]

I don't see why that makes him not lynchable.

[iguanaiguana]

Well I don't think he's the best lynch based on the two posts he made that had content. Hoping he shows up to play now that Thanksgiving is over.

[EFHW]

@Space, what was the statement Galz made that you thought was contradicting faust?

@Haddock, I will reread you. Also, it's not a stretch to think schadd might have been recruited N1.

[EFHW]

I haven't played with Jake in awhile.  Not that I want him to go back to cluttering the thread, and maybe he doesn't do that anymore, but why is he so quiet?

[faust]

Request prod on Dylan

Sent.

[gkrieg13]

I think more people should be looking at EFHW. I’ll make a case when I have a computer, but that won’t be for a while.