So the unknown on unknown votes were MiX->LL, mcmc; ADK->Dylan, mcmc; EFHW->mcmc; Dylan->LL; and whatever votes Space did but didn't list here. The simple fact is, 6+space's votes just isn't enough to say anything about whether scum had a no bussing policy in place for D1. Space does admittedly say "I'm not sure how that helps us much at all here," but then proceeds to defend mcmc a bit and shade MiX and LL, which is strange because mcmc received 3 votes and LL received 2, so I would think from this LL would be included with mcmc rather than MiX, who voted for both LL and mcmc.
Okay, you're missing the point slightly, but you actually
have pointed out that I missed one possible bussing vote, which seemed to be the thing MiX was trying hard to accuse me of but messing up on :-P I missed ADK's brief stint voting for Dylan from #158-188.
It changes very little, but it
does change the thing Dylan seems to be objecting to most, which was my conclusion about there being one scum in {mcmc,LL} if there was any off-wagon bussing at all. That's because I was counting all pairs (outside of the Galz wagon) that could still be a scum-on-scum vote. While I found five, all five of them contained either mcmc or LL, hence my statement about either having a scum in {mcmc,LL} or no off-wagon bussing. I was literally summarising the pairs in a concise way, and not injecting any opinion. It wasn't about anything as complicated as counting who was voted for how many times, or trying to spin things for a particular argument, which is what Dylan seems to be implying in the comment above.
However, when you add that sixth pair of ADK-Dylan, then it's no longer possible to pull out a single pair of players such that all the possible pairs contain them, and we'd have to add one or other of ADK and Dylan into the {mcmc,LL} bracket to cover all the bases.
And as I've said a bunch of times, this is a
really minor point that just might be interesting later on when there have been more flips. At the end of the day, it's perfectly possible that we saw no off-Galz bussing, plus early or copious on-Galz bussing, and/or that the scum-team wasn't even thinking in terms of bussing at all.
Actually, that inconsistency sounds just like Space was talking just to make up something to talk about and trying to make up conclusions to fit the narrative they wanted rather than looking at what they were posting.
vote: Space
I think you're accusing me of analysing the votes instead of what the people were saying, in which case I'm guilty as charged, because I find it quite informative to look at the votes most of the time, since those are the mechanism through which the game actually operates. It's not like I'm building scum-cases or anything here, and other than missing out on one brief vote, I was only stating factual stuff in a re-organised way that might be a bit easier to think and reason about later, so I'm not sure what hidden scum-agenda you even think that might be serving.