Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Hydrad]

A smart town vig would not have shot last night.

I agree with this part.

So normally I would agree with you, but as he essentially "claimed the role" - wouldn't PPS assume they were going to be the Target of the NK last night?

even if he full claimed it scum probably doesn't mind it to much.

also he hasn't really claimed it. hes just saying it at least exists in the game. If anything since hes position 13 there is a high chance hes a VT.

[Swowl]

A smart town vig would not have shot last night.

I agree with this part.

So normally I would agree with you, but as he essentially "claimed the role" - wouldn't PPS assume they were going to be the Target of the NK last night?

even if he full claimed it scum probably doesn't mind it to much.

also he hasn't really claimed it. hes just saying it at least exists in the game. If anything since hes position 13 there is a high chance hes a VT.

OK I actually did not think it through - he is more likely to shoot incorrectly than correctly so why would he get the NK (check on that one, thatnks).

But the last part bothers me - If he is saying that he 100% knows it is in the game because he went that station and it was taken... why couldn't the other person who bid that station just of gone for the other PR? (cuz only one power can be taken from each slot)

[Hydrad]

But the last part bothers me - If he is saying that he 100% knows it is in the game because he went that station and it was taken... why couldn't the other person who bid that station just of gone for the other PR? (cuz only one power can be taken from each slot)

ya that part is still possible. I'm not sure if he didn't know thats how it worked or if he didn't feel like saying both of them or whatever. But ya basically we know there is at least a Vig or a rolestopper in the game. as long as PPS is telling the truth.

[Witherweaver]

I like Vote: DatSwan

[Swowl]

I like Vote: DatSwan

Whysies?

[Jimmmmm]

@Jimmmmm, you're the one whose opinion of Robz I was actually asking for.

I still lean Town on him. I think his sudden apparently strong scum read on me was at least in part to see what reactions he'd get (I hope it's not too soon for me to point that out). The only potential bite he got was Cuzz, who I still lean scum on.

[Witherweaver]

I like Vote: DatSwan

Whysies?

I got slipped a note in class saying that I should.

[Swowl]

I like Vote: DatSwan

Whysies?

I got slipped a note in class saying that I should.

... from?

[Hydrad]

ok so I've been saying I suspect someone for a couple days now.

I think I've waited long enough to let you know who it is.

I believe the person is WW. I think he is scum.

And I also would like WW to tell me if he is a VT or not.

Vote: WW

i'll also say that I still like e for voting but i'd say an e vote is like 20% sure where as for WW i'd bump it to like 70%.

[Witherweaver]

ok so I've been saying I suspect someone for a couple days now.

I think I've waited long enough to let you know who it is.

I believe the person is WW. I think he is scum.

And I also would like WW to tell me if he is a VT or not.

Vote: WW

i'll also say that I still like e for voting but i'd say an e vote is like 20% sure where as for WW i'd bump it to like 70%.

Well I'm not going to tell you that. But I can tell you that I'm not a one-shot PGO.

[Witherweaver]

And I can now tell you guys that Hydrad is fairly likely town.

[Swowl]

ok so I've been saying I suspect someone for a couple days now.

I think I've waited long enough to let you know who it is.

I believe the person is WW. I think he is scum.

And I also would like WW to tell me if he is a VT or not.

Vote: WW

i'll also say that I still like e for voting but i'd say an e vote is like 20% sure where as for WW i'd bump it to like 70%.

Well I'm not going to tell you that. But I can tell you that I'm not a one-shot PGO.

will you answer me?

[Swowl]

And I can now tell you guys that Hydrad is fairly likely town.

agreed.

[Witherweaver]

ok so I've been saying I suspect someone for a couple days now.

I think I've waited long enough to let you know who it is.

I believe the person is WW. I think he is scum.

And I also would like WW to tell me if he is a VT or not.

Vote: WW

i'll also say that I still like e for voting but i'd say an e vote is like 20% sure where as for WW i'd bump it to like 70%.

Well I'm not going to tell you that. But I can tell you that I'm not a one-shot PGO.

will you answer me?

Nope!

[pingpongsam]

Hydrad was always town. Tell us something that wasn’t obvious already. Pretty sure WW is town, too, though even without the rankling.

[pingpongsam]

Totes fine with a Datswan lyncheroonie as well.

[Hydrad]

Hydrad was always town. Tell us something that wasn’t obvious already. Pretty sure WW is town, too, though even without the rankling.

But now that means I'm like supertown.

I call dibs on being the day 2 IC now even if one didn't appear.

[Witherweaver]

Hydrad was always town. Tell us something that wasn’t obvious already. Pretty sure WW is town, too, though even without the rankling.

It was not obvious that it is now more obvious.

[2.71828.....]

So. Robz.

D1 he starts with the "joke" about claiming then says it is bad until D2.

He moves around to a few different people early (which is normal Robz D1), then when the options for lynch seem to narrow to myself, raptor, or Awaclus he votes Raptor and stays there until the end.

Fairly non-descript D1 for Robz, but that isn't too surprising. It isn't necessarily scummy, but there are a few things I think point to scum!Robz:
1) the whole mass claim joke seemed forced.
2) his position in and about the raptor wagon. He votes Raptor early(ish) for his lurking/inactivity but then as the lynch looks more and more inevitable he makes strong statements about raptor being town. Again, forced.

And now he comes out D2 with the confidence of a cop saying everyone should vote jimmmmm but gives no explanation. It all just feels suspicious to me

[iguanaiguana]

Vote Count 2.2

Jimmmmm (2): Robz888, Cuzz
Robz888 (1): 2.71828...
2.71828... (2): pingpongsam, Jimmmmm
Datswan (1): Witherweaver
Witherweaver (1): Hydrad

Not Voting (4): DatSwan, schadd, Awaclus, SpaceAnemone

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Day 2 lasts until Sunday May 20 at 9 PM.

Mod note: Prod sent to schadd

[Hydrad]

Unvote

for now. my read on WW is changing i think. dang it.

[Robz888]

So. Robz.

D1 he starts with the "joke" about claiming then says it is bad until D2.

He moves around to a few different people early (which is normal Robz D1), then when the options for lynch seem to narrow to myself, raptor, or Awaclus he votes Raptor and stays there until the end.

Fairly non-descript D1 for Robz, but that isn't too surprising. It isn't necessarily scummy, but there are a few things I think point to scum!Robz:
1) the whole mass claim joke seemed forced.
2) his position in and about the raptor wagon. He votes Raptor early(ish) for his lurking/inactivity but then as the lynch looks more and more inevitable he makes strong statements about raptor being town. Again, forced.

And now he comes out D2 with the confidence of a cop saying everyone should vote jimmmmm but gives no explanation. It all just feels suspicious to me

Lol. Alright, I think I'm sufficiently outed. Probably I was already. And I'm not going to get the Jimmmm lynch through without revealing more, since there just isn't really a case to make on him.

I know Jimmmm is scum for PR reasons.

Should I reveal my draft number before we go to night, given that I'm highly likely to die now?

[Hydrad]

oh well i'll jump on that wagon.

Vote: Jimmm

[2.71828.....]

Unvote

The only PR that can give that type of confidence is alignment cop (maybe tracker/watcher but that still shouldn't be 100% confidence like Robz seems to have), and I still don't get the whole joke about claiming on D1 if Robz is indeed the cop.

Unless he is the JOAT 1-shot version. Which actually makes sense with mass claiming so he knows who to reload with that shot.

Ok, I am fine with Robz maintaining ambiguity in whether he is JOAT/2-shot cop and following him to lynch jimmmmm.

Vote: Jimmmmm

[2.71828.....]

And I think not revealing your draft number is fine.