Reasons for voting EFHW:
1) I have the same general feeling about EFHW in this game I had in Shakespeare, where she turned out to be scum. This is hard to quantify, since it's a feeling.
Reasons to not vote EFHW:
1) Ash is tunneling this case hard, and I have somewhat of a scum read on Ash.
So all in all, not strong reasons on either side (I don't buy the "scumslip"), but that doesn't mean I should vote for EFHW.
Reasons for voting Eevee:
1) Does have a history of flipping reads in relatively short time periods. Spiritbears and Mail-mi were the two biggest to stand out for me.
2) I have a general feeling that Eevee is town, which is the same feeling I had in mean girls.
Reasons for not voting Eevee:
1) I have a general feeling that Eevee is town.
So I have the same feelings about two different players that I had in others games, and both of them were scum in that game. I think if my only basis for voting EFHW is the similarity of the read, I should vote Eevee instead, as I'm more convinced by points others have brought up and don't trust the player driving EFHW's wagon the hardest.
Vote: Eevee
(Another suspicious thing Xeiron did, while I'm here: As soon as I asked him for some names, he immediately threw out four names! That's a lot! But when TA and I asked him why he had those names, he disappeared!)