Ok, just going through the player list:
Witherweaver - not so sure here, I have trouble reading WW in general. Seemed scummy early on but I think that's probably just a lens I'm seeing him through.
LaLight - I've been giving him a D1 pass, but I'm still suspicious about his SK hunting and the way he handled putting mail-mi at L-1.
silverspawn - seems his usual towny self. I'm actually strangely confident about this one
4. gkrieg13 - is very towny, but I don't think I've played a game where he's scum. In fact, I think the only game I read where he was scum was Fanfic Mafia and he was towny there. So uh, let's look at him tomorrow?
5. faust - trying to start easy wagons, misconstruing people's posts to make them sound scummy. I didn't like his interaction with gkrieg about the "tell me my scum meta" thing
6. Roadrunner7671 - hard to read, since he's in high school and that takes up a lot of time. Achoo. I just sneezed.
7. Joseph2302 - is joseph!joseph. Probably town. by the way, did he claim scum yet this game?
8. SpaceAnemone - has been pretty absent, with a lot of jokey posts early on. I'm suspicious but not enough to start a wagon today. If they continue like this we should lynch them fo sho.
9. J Reggie - towny, despite what everyone says. This is the only one I'm 100% sure on. Would not lynch.
10. schadd - confusing. could actually be scum but I'm giving him a D1 pass
11. iguanaiguana - seems like town!ii. Would not lynch
12. mail-mi - scummy. would lynch