Alright I'm here again. Currently reading back, I'll post general thoughts along the way. It's posts like these where I tend to accuse everyone in a disorganized fashion. Are you ready? Here it goes.
Because we don't know what the major arcana are, I do not want to massclaim. Remember how much that would have overpowered death? Not sure if the same mechanic will be used here.
Doesn't want to massclaim because he's scum? Volt was the same way. Something to think about.
Can I ask a theory/setup question?
I've never played a game with multiple bad guy factions before. Looking at the card list, there's some listed "werewolf" which sounds cool, but is otherwise just a second mafia? Also, if there are multiple factions, are they smaller than usual?
LOL if ash if WW
Just got to shraeye's breadcrumb, he didn't make any misspellings in the rest of the post. If shraeye and Grujah are masons, then they should have had strong reasons to believe that one of Eevee, Galz, and Robz was scum based on Insom's info (not really useful just an observation).
Galz, Robz, Voltgloss, Lekkit, ashersky all voted for me.
Voltgloss I have the hardest time believing that he would think my statement was a slip. Lekkit and ash look most like a wagon jumpers...
keeping this in the back of my mind for now.
WTH?
This is not anywhere near "0% of flipping town"
I am the only one who read that as - "the other scum team than one in which eevee/galz/robz are"?
This is exactly how I read it too.
vote: Robz888
I think it's an honest mistake though and not worth a vote.
Wow, really trying hard not to be a wagon jumper. (Of course, he jumped on my wagon then soon retreated from that.)
Woah woah woah! Lots happened!
Uhh ok. So Eevee's the Bulletproof guy. He's now an IC now? Cool, so that narrows it down to Robz and Galzria.
There's the scumdayvig and the towndayvig. Robz tries to pass himself off as the towndayvig, but the way he used it seemed like he was in a rush, and would be worried that he wouldn't be able to use his dayvig. Towndayvig wouldn't have had to worry about that. Vigginig is often a negative utility, so it's not too big of a deal if they got lynched without using their dayvig.
Galzria is supposedly the Strongman (?) Vigilante, right? Well that really sucks. If he's scum, he's going to be shooting Eevee tonight. But I guess he couldn't for some WIFOM. Hmm.
I think I'm going to Vote: Robz. Galzria seems scarier as scum, but Robz's actions so far have been scummy, brash, and paranoid compared to Galz. And of course, if Robz flips town, we can always go after Galz.
If Galz then flips scum, then Insomniac has some explaining to do.
I could see this post as WW-ish. If there was an opportunity to treat Eevee as IC, this would have been he time to do so. He then knew that Robz and Galz were innocent. Notice the last sentence. He doesn't say Insom would be scum. Just that he had some explaining to do. Cause Insomniac could have still been town. If he was town (which he was), Eevee was scum and Archetype would not have wanted people thinking that. (This is a whole bunch of conspiracy theory lol)
Town: I suggest we lynch Robz, and I'll still NK Eevee. This cannot be stopped.
I say don't do it. We lynch Robz and see his flip. If he's scum, then I guess Eevee's not a confirmed Townie and then Galzria is in the clear.
If he's Town, Eevee is an IC, and it doesn't matter what we suggest. Scum!Galzria will do whatever he wants, and then we lynch him tommorow. If he really is scum, he'll NK Eevee, eliminating our IC, and there's nothing we can do about it.
Question: (for cayvie ir whoever can help me understand this) is there a scum 1-shot Strongman Vigilante? Or is it just a Town 1-shot Strongman Vigilante?
Interesting...
BTW - Grujah shooting questions and posts in a rapidly fashing, like right now - town Grujah.
Take a note for further games.
Noted. When you're scum in future games, you're going down.
Just got to my late night drunkish rave of posts. #614 is where I finally start using my brain in the whole game.
#622 Archetype kinda gives up on his "Eevee = IC" idea. Now that it was kinda obvious at that point that Eevee was scum. They might have discussed that in their QT.
Well wait a second, if Eevee is self aligned, then would he have a QT?
Unvote.
HAHHAHAHA. Well, he intended to vote again shortly after. That didn't last long.
On the theory on ash being SK based on his hedging after Eevee's fake fullclaim, the possibility of strong, but it's not a 100% conviction. It is screwy how he hadn't realized by that point that Galz was conf-town. What's more noticeable is Archetype from a WW standpoint. I still think Axxle is a SK possibility.
Archetype claimed Roleblocker. He blocked Galz. It was a nice attempt at trying to prevent Galz from shooting Eevee just in case he did that, if Arche is WW. Reading back, this scenario seems entirely plausible, except... what WW roleblocks in this setup? The Alpha? It's a mystery. He could just be making all of it up,
as he himself described. I noticed that Archetype has been giving plenty of hypothetical situations in which he is scum, and I'm finding that to be fishy. Also, if he is scum, he would have HAD to make up that hypothetical situation to see if the claim would be believable in the first place.
So,those are my thoughts after another long absence.
Author
Topic: Mafia XVIII: Major Arcana Mafia II (Werewolves win!) (Read 110030 times)