Ok, we got stuck apparently.
Rereading was rough. I think I had too much conformation bias to actually learn something new out of it.. I Believe UoS and Awa really are 3d party, which means we don't have too rush killing them off and other than them- Ash seems like the scummiest one through the game from the masons perspective, doctor-claim and the resurrection of Hydrad aside. Chairs agreeing with this makes this worth a shot from my perspective. Especially since we are plus one town with hydrad today.
An ash-lynch would be saying a lot about us masons too, not that we're scum if Ash flips, but that we are kind of lost in our reading. Anyhow, as long as Ash is in the game I won't feel very safe townwise.. someone of Ash/1 mason need to go somewhere during the lane, I think.
I don't know, if you feel this is a risky move- going for the claimed doc and all- I'm happy for an Awa-lynch as well, but I honestly believe this is our best chance to hit scum.