I'll go ahead and throw out my preferred order:
EFHW, faust, swowl, dylan, mathdude, pubby, WCD, Glooble/Iguana
This is based on MiX's final stated reads, where he agrees with WCD that town are among WCD, pubby, MiX, Glooble, Iguana but says there's no reason to think mathdude is town (I just quoted this post above.) Nothing's really changed since then to make MiX's reads out of date, so we should use MiX's reads.
My preference would be for Glooble to alter the order of {faust, swowl, dylan, mathdude} however he wants & publish the final claim order for us to begin using immediately. We should be done with mass claim ASAP so that we're not rushing the exile. Short days don't give us enough time to argue a ton about claim order, so if anyone has serious reservations about it, they should speak up quickly.