With apologies to Awaclus for disagreeing on what's generally good collaborative play, here's where I'm at with everything so far, based on reading things this evening:
kkrieg (13 game posts) -- inexperienced, but putting reads out there. No red lights yet, and didn't flail or get defensive when LL voted for her, which is a sort of cool that's tough to fake. Probable town, though I acknowledge a built-in bias where I'd rather keep newbies in a newbie game at least past D1.
LL (50 game posts) -- more prolific than I'd realised. Seems like his helpful self in terms of trying to diffuse RR's joke in a contained way. I think the brief kkrieg vote was townie.
Awaclus (13 game posts) -- is very Awaclus. His playstyle gives very little away in terms of leaving room for scumslips, but the fact he's been talking in paragraphs occasionally is encouraging. Town side of the heap.
Space (19 game posts) -- spaaaaaaace :-)
TWM (47 game posts) -- engaging a lot. Seems to have a thing against schadd that extends into meta rather than scumreads maybe? Also seems to be pretty conscious of how he's seen (e.g. at #208), which is something I'm scumread for from time to time, but he seems to be doing okay with it. What were his previous games? Background reading/revision is in order if he's actually a ninja scum player, because he's giving off a pretty townie vibe to me.
IDP/e (3 posts from e, 17 from IDP) -- leaning townish for meta reasons, though I think schadd's narrative makes that look more cut-and-dried that it is. Need to keep an eye on e.
Jake (24 game posts) -- Getting a little flustered by votes on him in a way that I think is similar to that recent blitz game, where he was the high-value scum target, but managed to stay under the radar during the majority of the conversation. OTOH, I like that his playstyle has gotten so much better lately, and I tend to scumread people pretty hard for pushing him based on his earlier play, which kind of biases me to the point where he's a nullish read here for now.
schadd (70 game posts) -- dominating the game in terms of posts, though maybe only about 3/4 of them make sense fully. Even then, that's a pretty high level of engagement. He's certainly been saying a lot of helpful stuff that's the kind of thing I'd have posted if I wasn't so distracted by getting older and stuff. Comes off a bit scummier in a targeted re-read, actually. Things like pushing TWM for the use of "probably" and complaining about Jake not responding to something that wasn't initially a question.. unless I'm mis-reading/misunderstanidng schadd there? Mild scum.
RR (25 game posts) -- The joke was not good, now is the fact that immediately afterwards he specifically drew attention to the implications of what might happen with other town PRs he could have outed (#53). I feel like it's well within RR's general meta, but I get so frustrated at that kind of "it was all a joke" play :-(