1. Robz888 - seems kinda town. I don't really buy the "leaning hard into his lackluster quote" as scum from him. I don't think his play has been that bad for the current F.ds meta where no one cares except McMc.
2. DatSwan sauce - I dunno I knew his alignment a few times when he was scum and saw little things he did as scum that were kinda clumsy and luckily people didn't pick up on them. At the same time I've seen him be clumsy town and sorta townslip his town mindset. And then people vote him anyway for the carelessness. Here I'm seeing careless town DatSwan, not clumsy scum DatSwan. This dude is gunna help us win.
3. faust - I'm not gunna just read him as town yet but Faust has not been scummy enough to lynch on D1.
4. SirClemens - Pretty null, but the way that people are defending a big bag of null makes me worry that he's scum and his team is trying to keep him alive. Great lynch choice!
5. mcmcsalot - If we lynch him, it would be like "Oh dang, he worked so hard and then we just lynched him." If he was scum, we'd all feel really good. But probably he's town so let's not do that.
6. Teproc - Just like Faust except from France.
7. pingpongsam - Dude was approaching the game from a town frame of mind. The way he was like "Iguana's long division method is null and void" comes from a town frame of mind. Scum doesn't think of that kinda stuff. Who care if some of his votes have been careless or bad when he is giving off town tells from his fundamental approach to the game?
8. Galzria - Dunno. But I leaned a little more towny because of the way that other people were calling him scum for kinda crappy reasons. It was like scum wanted him dead.
9. iguanaiguana - thankfully he could IC himself this game, otherwise he was gunna get lynched for sure in this game packed full of superstars.
10. Cuzz - Just like Cuzz in M100. Town frame of mind up in his head.
11. The_Wine_Merchant - Null. Can't remember him much.
12. SpaceAnemone - Yeah they could be scum. They're playing a bit defensively; their votes aren't great. I could vote here but for some reason I just don't like mislynching Space and I'm not feeling it like super really strongly that they are scum. I do think that McMc is right, they're being a bit different than normal. But maybe that's because this is a hardcore reads based game so far.
13. LaLight - this is my favorite lynch because I think he's been insincere and a bit opportunistic. I could make the case, but it would take me like two hours because I'm slow. Gross.
Furthermore: I don't really want to lynch Teproc, Galzria, Faust, McMc, or Robz because all of them are superstars and none of them have been super scummy today. If they are all town, that's great! Most likely prolly one is scum, maybe 2, but I have no clue which.
Furthermore: POSSIBLY one of my town frame of mind people: Cuzz, PPS, DatSwan, McMc, is just doing a good job of faking it. If so, I think we can catch them by their voting patterns etc. later on.
So I would lynch: LaLight, Clemens, Space, TWM - in that order I guess.
I could vote Space but what if they are town? I'd be bummed.
Is this a bit you're doing this game ? Because I'm getting tired with it. I have no idea where you stand on anything.
Is the above good enough for you? I am time limited this game, that's why I am not fully fleshing out all my thoughts and supporting everything I say with quotes and stuff.