mcmcsalot was definitely town, and is an experienced player, so let's look at his reads, shall we?
He started the case on MiX, based on the belief that MiX was signaling to the traitor. Also, this post, which I don't understand well enough to summarize:
MiX am I correct you have not been mafia yet on this forum, only town and sk.
MiX appears to be playing a game based on a team motivation. He is pushing and doing things that are anti town but also not from some misguided town perspective. This yea I was wrong is very sloppy and not something town MiX is likely to do (make such a poor play in the first place, not the fact that he admitted it was a poor play)
Also I really think he’s scum trying to prompt and provide a method of he traitor to claim promoter and reveal himself to mafia. Which I think people don’t understand how good of a move that is for the mafia team.
Space is towny, so is galz and chairs. I agree with joth about aroshapes post being scummy but I still find him overall towny, maybe I need to reread ari.
Later says he thinks ari is towny and joth slightly scummy for pushing ari.
Then he gets drunk and says Swan is an IC. Make of that what you will.
After the DAMA he votes for Space for wording a post in a confusing (misleading?) way. Note he previously said he found Space towny. I don't buy his argument re: that particular post really at all. It felt to me very in line with Space's town meta.
He analyzes all the votes on MiX and ADK, chides MiX for claiming VT, then says he would vote ADK over ari.
Finally he changes his vote to ADK and his final contribution is this quote, which for the record I don't really understand:
The scrambling is being done by a limited number of people which means MiX is town and scum isn’t helping us consolidate anywhere else