My case against Faust:
Reason number one. Unexplained vote.
Vote: ADK
Even after repeated pressure from me and ADK, Faust has refused to provide justification for this vote. I've repeatedly stated why this is super anti town, I don't want to sound like a broken record. If anyone needs to know why this is scummy, ask. Or re-read me.
Reason number two. General unhelpful-ness. Here are some of the choicest Faust quotes of this game.
Unrelated note: Well done gkrieg.
If town guesses right and lynches scum, it even increases our chance of lynching scum to 100%.
I sure hope we're in one of the scenarios that have only 1 scum!
I think he's a bit towny.
The above quote is unhelpful for providing no reasons, although making a town read is usually helpful.
Can you guys just move on already?
Faust seems to be gravitating towards one liners that don't actually say anything, and not contributing nearly enough. However, he has done the occasional helpful post. I just don't believe these outdo his lack of helpfulness. Useful quotes include:
Here"s a notable setup point worth discussing: We can still lynch whoever we want on D2 if we do it before the 72 hour deadline for the Gladiator expires.
Unrelated note: Well done gkrieg.
This reminds me: What's gkrieg's meta? With his, feel free to explain chairs joth and Galzria's metas as well, I just realized I haven't played with them yet.
Let's just say if gkrieg were the Traitor, we'd already know...
Seriously, gkrieg tends to have pretty good reads as town but for some reason people read him scummy and he gets mislynched frequently. As scum he's much easier to detect IRL. chairs is like always kind of excited when he starts playing, and then something terrible happens in his life and he can't participate. He's also very much a gut feeling kind of player. joth I feel I haven't really played with enough yet. Galzria's current meta is unfortunately that he lurks until he is replaced.
Finally, I also just get a scummy vibe from him. I try to ignore feelings most of the time, but I find in mafia they sometimes serve a purpose. Feel free to argue.
Vote:Faust