Okay, I need to get posting some thoughts!
First up, town: Calamitas and Silver both seem more solvy and helpful here than I've seen them elsewhere.
Nulls: RR, Iguana, diedre.
Slight scum: Mail-mi, because of the way the mislynch of teamlyle got started.
Scum: Chairs. I'm not sure whether pushing that wagon to L-2 is a great idea now that we have a precedent for invisible votes, though -- would people in general be comfortable with that?
Really not sure: Gkrieg. I mean, I want to believe he's solvy town, but there are a few tiny threads that don't quite sit right for me. The first is the exchange below with Silver, since I agree that Seprix's words as quoted look like a hedgey attack, rather than a defence.
Kinda defends silverspawn here:
On the other hand EFHW's and iguana's reactions to my posts just seem more natural for someone who's a lot more social than me. Silver's looking to exploit the opportunity
Yeah, SS's reads feel opportunistic to me as well. He plays that way though, but considering he's been scum pretty much every time lately, I would still present that as part of a potential case.
That is not a defense. That is an attack.
The second thing was that in post #252, he picked out Seprix's use of the word "trait" in post #237 ("Also, can double voting or hating be a town trait?"), and said "Not too much to go off of, but he was definitely dropping that he was a traitor like the whole game". That would be fine, but Seprix's words were mimicking Chair's language of post #230 ("I'd actually argue hated is more likely a Town trait, in this theme, but that's just me."), and given that he's also building a case on Chairs, something feels contradictory about his not mentioning that.
Last and possibly least, there was a comment quite early in D1 from Gkrieg about liking the new Mail-mi, but at that point I didn't think Mail-mi had said all that much, so I found it odd. I have no idea what Mail-mi was like previously, though, and haven't read any Mail-mi games, so it may just be such a marked difference that even with a handful of posts it was obvious.