OK so I've reread yuma now. Couple of things come out of it.
Firstly, his part in the argument about whether we should talk about switches. I'd forgotten he had such a big say in it, but he does end up saying quite a lot. The weird thing is I agree that completely censoring a topic was a bad thing, but the whole thing went on for so long that everyone who said anything in it ended up feeling a bit scummy to me. So yeah minor scum points for that, he makes no posts except about the switch discussion for a large chunk of D1.
After that he makes a lot of anecdotes about previous games, still not really contributing much. First major point is his case against faust, which actually isn't a bad case it seems to me, I can see where he comes from. Not much to deduce from that. (I want to apologise to WW, on reread I can definitely get behind the scumread on faust, he somehow looks scummier now that I know he's town than he did at the time.) Then he refuses to continue defending his viewpoint on faust, which actually reads fairly genuine, so his case on faust is still null to me.
The ash thing. I'mma take back what I said about WW. On reread, yuma and WW saw ash's behaviour as being within his meta right from the start. This makes the later defense of ash, because there's two of them doing it, seem much better generally, for some reason. So unvote: WW.
D2 yuma seems way more invested in the game. I can only assume that he's aware that his defense of ash is going to look suspicious. So he's contributing more. Also the game has just got more interesting. But there's not much content in his posts, just like there hasn't been much content in anyone's posts today. Other than yuma's feelings rant there's not much going on. The rant again feels genuine, no way to take anything from it.
The main thing I don't like about yuma is his tendency to keep going back to meta anecdotes. Bothers me a bit, like he's not contributing based on the content of the current game. That's the main thing that comes out at me on reread. Not enough for a vote at this point.
Bah, today is tough. Gonna leave my vote on noone for now.