Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

Also, ADK, why give it to me? I didn't claim any needed item. DatSwan at least had a telescope in his list, and that may have been a roundabout way of hinting at a magnifying glass. Did you not trust them (like I didn't Joseph). But then why me?

I don't get the whole hinting thing. Like, we did the plan so we could include the explicit item we were looking for. I did not even stop to consider that someone might have put something vague in there.

[A Drowned Kernel]

I have been item less since after N1.

Also, this is why I don't trust the anyone can win with the three pieces of the owl. I mean I started with a piece, how am I supposed to collect the other 2, if I have to give it away?

That said, not sure why joth would mislead on that.

This is a lie; I gave the magnifying glass to scola night one

vote: scola

OK, ADK is scum. I received nothing.

And everyone else who tried giving an item but was intercepted was told that it was intercepted. (right?)

I do agree with MiX that scum might be willing to enter a 1v1 based on #s here. But one way to help prove my innocence would be for other generous townies to claim. I mean, how many can there be?

Also, ADK, why give it to me? I didn't claim any needed item. DatSwan at least had a telescope in his list, and that may have been a roundabout way of hinting at a magnifying glass. Did you not trust them (like I didn't Joseph). But then why me?

I had to give it to someone, it didn't occur to me that swan might have lied about his item. You seemed reasonably trustworthy at the time

[A Drowned Kernel]

@ADK: Did you receive confirmation that you successfully gave away the item?

Yes, and I can't qoute exactly but gloole's message implied that scola did receive it

[faust]

Weird stuff.

[faust]

Could both of you check back with Glooble?

[scolapasta]

As scum, why would I say I did not receive the item (and immediately have a provable lie to ADK)?

If I didn't want anyone to have it, it'd be better to just say I got it and gave it away in N2. As scum, I would even have known who "we" were going to NK and claim to give to that person, so it'd be lost. (after all, town graverobber is dead).

[scolapasta]

Also, ADK, why give it to me? I didn't claim any needed item. DatSwan at least had a telescope in his list, and that may have been a roundabout way of hinting at a magnifying glass. Did you not trust them (like I didn't Joseph). But then why me?

I don't get the whole hinting thing. Like, we did the plan so we could include the explicit item we were looking for. I did not even stop to consider that someone might have put something vague in there.

I agree, that the hinting idea is might just be plain wrong. I'm only basing this on after the fact that:
• Swan was a modified* motion detector / tracker
• claimed to need the telescope (none of the other items seem relevant, but who knows?)
• no one else said they needed a magnifying glass (though not everyone made lists)
• magnifying glass is reasonable close to telescope, at least in concept

* maybe this was obvious to others already, but "modified" to me seems like you are your PR, if/when you get your item.

[scolapasta]

Could both of you check back with Glooble?

Check what? That I should've gotten it? Sure, I can ask. (though I'd assume then he'd also have reminded me on N2 that I had to give it away)

[Glooble]

I have made a mistake. I am sorry I don't know how it happened. I somehow failed to send scola the PM that he received the magnifying glass.

I had a very redundant system for making sure this didn't happen and I have no idea how it failed.

I think the right think to do is just to admit this. I am sorry for anything that was messed up by this.

[mail-mi]

I have made a mistake. I am sorry I don't know how it happened. I somehow failed to send scola the PM that he received the magnifying glass.

I think the right think to do is just to admit this. I am sorry for anything that was messed up by this.

Well, that clears this 1v1. unvote

[MiX]

I never moved my vote 

Also that changes everything, although the 1v1 made no sense.

Luckily, mod confirm of ADK having that item means nothing for who's scum, unless we want to mindread the mod.

...do we mindread the mod?

[MiX]

Scola, would you have to give the magnifying glass this night now?

[scolapasta]

D'oh! OK, I also take back ADK is scum. Or least for now.

[scolapasta]

Scola, would you have to give the magnifying glass this night now?

I've sent a message to mod, asked him to clarify whatever he feels is appropriate in main thread.

[scolapasta]

Scola, would you have to give the magnifying glass this night now?

I've sent a message to mod, asked him to clarify whatever he feels is appropriate in main thread.

i.e. I'd rather we all hear it from him directly, than from me.

[Eevee]

vote: LaLight

Mostly because (A) we need a wagon today and (B) I am ridiculously sure MiX is town and I like his reasoning, and faust is generally a strong player who I’m also townreading, though less strongly, so this seems like the right place to sheep. If I have time to do some rereading of LaLight of my own I’ll do that today.

Why are you ridiculously sure of Mix?

[Glooble]

Outside I picked up a small package lying on the ground. It read "please deliver to scolapasta".

Wow, I thought. Someone really screwed up on this one.


I don't think I should confirm anything else in thread.

Vote Count 3.3

faust (1): LaLight
Joseph2303 (2): Eevee, skip wooznum
MiX (1): Joseph2303
LaLight (3): MiX, faust, jotheonah
Skip wooznum (1): scolapasta
scolapasta (1): A Drowned Kernel
Not voting (2): sudgy, mail-mi
With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Day 3 will end at 2:30 pm ET on Wednesday, May 13th.

[scolapasta]

Hey all, I have the magnifying glass. Who wants it?

[scolapasta]

(if no one, does that mean it was in fact swan?)

[A Drowned Kernel]

Poop

unvote

[LaLight]

but who needs a knife? that's weird

[sudgy]

but who needs a knife? that's weird

Glooble told me it has a passive ability, so I'm guessing that it's something similar to the hat.

Also, sorry guys, but my homework is harder than I thought.  I'll still try to get my thoughts out there some time tonight, but it will be later than I originally thought.

[scolapasta]

but who needs a knife? that's weird

Glooble told me it has a passive ability, so I'm guessing that it's something similar to the hat.

Also, sorry guys, but my homework is harder than I thought.  I'll still try to get my thoughts out there some time tonight, but it will be later than I originally thought.

You're saying it affects whoever is holding the knife? But you don't k ow what? In the case of the hat, it seemed Awaclus knew what the passive ability was. Why wouldn't that happen here too?

(I had been thinking the baseball cap could also be passive - maybe loved. But again, I would've expected mail-mi to know that.)

What kind of homework?

 

[sudgy]

but who needs a knife? that's weird

Glooble told me it has a passive ability, so I'm guessing that it's something similar to the hat.

Also, sorry guys, but my homework is harder than I thought.  I'll still try to get my thoughts out there some time tonight, but it will be later than I originally thought.

You're saying it affects whoever is holding the knife? But you don't k ow what? In the case of the hat, it seemed Awaclus knew what the passive ability was. Why wouldn't that happen here too?

(I had been thinking the baseball cap could also be passive - maybe loved. But again, I would've expected mail-mi to know that.)

What kind of homework?

All I know is that it gives me a passive ability, but that I don't know what it does (it can be useful to get out of certain situations or something like that, don't quite remember the wording).  I'm guessing Awaclus' case is different from the knife and the hat.

Quantum mechanics.

[faust]

A knife is not exactly a pro-town item it would seem, and now it is revealed that it in fact does something on its own. Looks like LaLight giving away the knife is some kind of framing job.