So, I generally like to reread by person and say what I think of each person.
MiX: Holy cow, MiX posts a lot. Anyway, I can see why he is always lynched. The way he plays just seems scummy. I understand that that's his meta and won't hold it against him. I forgot that he had that whole weird claiming things with Didds at first. It is weird that he went after Joth hard at first but then later started ultra-buddying him and then started saying he was so much town that anybody who wanted to lynch him was scum. MiX never provides a reason for any of these changes. In the end, MiX posted an insane amount, but didn't commit to much in all of it. I feel like I just can't really read him right now, so null for now.
mail-mi: I already said what I thought earlier, and still think the same after rereading him. He hasn't posted that much, dragged RVS longer than it needed to, and the only posts of substance he's made are related to skip vs mail-mi, and then one post going after Eevee. I actually lean a bit scum here just because of how unhelpful he's been.
Galzria: He has mainly just been arguing against other people's conclusions, which is interesting. His biggest thing is coming out hard against it being a 1v1. I would say null, but with maybe a tiny scum lean because he hasn't said much other than arguing against the 1v1.
skip: Wow, this reread changed my opinion on him. Everything has been mostly about his plan and such, but it all came across to me as genuine. I now townread skip.
Didds: Very friendly (reminds me of Eevee in that way). However, there is actually not much of substance besides that. She does seem pretty busy so I'll give her a pass, so null for now.
scolapasta: Not too many posts, but tries to contribute with most posts. However, there is not much to go off of, so null, but leaning town slightly.
LaLight: Holy cow, the lurker. I didn't realize you have 8 short posts, and that's it. Votes for joth with no reason, then votes for mail-mi. Slight scum just for lurking.
Awaclus: Holy cow, another lurker. He is against the item plans, then votes for skip once the 1v1 pops up. Recently said he could vote off of the 1v1. I don't remember him lurking this hard before, so slight scum on him too, but more than LaLight because there's even less substance in his posts.
DatSwan: Not much, really. Gut feeling is more towny, but brain is telling me that he hasn't really contributed much, leaning more scummy, so I guess I'm in the middle here too.
Joth: Great contributor, so definitely off the chopping block for now. But I could still see this just being a masterful scum play. Cautious townread for now.
faust: Maybe I've just been reading too much and my brain is turning to mush, but I didn't see much that would tell me anything about him. I seem to remember him being hard to read in the past. Null, I guess.
Joseph: Not said enough to make a decision.
sudgy: obvtown
ADK: I keep forgetting he's in this game. He's also not really said too much.
Eevee: Not said too much, and has even admitted to it.
I feel like I got tired towards the end there... Anyway, in conclusion, Vote: mail-mi. He is on the scummier side of my list, and will be much more likely to be lynched than a lot of the others. Even if he's town, he has not contributed too much yet (to his own admission) and so we won't lose much if we mislynch him.
Author
Topic: BM30: MacGuffin Mafia (Game Over, Scum and Treasure Hunter win!) (Read 197466 times)