Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[A Drowned Kernel]

I buy the argument that skip is scummy for making this a 1v1 but then expects to not be lynched when mail-mi flips town.

Why would scum put themselves in that position?

[MiX]

I buy the argument that skip is scummy for making this a 1v1 but then expects to not be lynched when mail-mi flips town.

Why would scum put themselves in that position?

It gives them someone to push and a smoke screen for anything else they do this day.

Do you think it's town vs town?

[A Drowned Kernel]

I buy the argument that skip is scummy for making this a 1v1 but then expects to not be lynched when mail-mi flips town.

Why would scum put themselves in that position?

It gives them someone to push and a smoke screen for anything else they do this day.

Do you think it's town vs town?

I'm at least willing to concede that it could be. But if there is scum in mail-mi and skip I'm more likely to think that it's mail-mi

[MiX]

Rereading thread now.

If joth had less votes I would vote for him, but I don't really think he's scum.

I'm also feeling a bit more comfortable with my MiX vote.  I remember in one RMM game I was in I was scum and had the power to secretly lynch someone when they were at L-1.  At one point someone got to L-2 and I freaked out, saying, "What if scum has the power to lynch early?  We shouldn't get people so close to being lynched!"  I didn't realize it then, but I was freaking out because I was trying to act like town, but I had the information scum has.  Thankfully, they didn't lynch me for it, but I don't want to repeat that mistake here.

I don't follow. What mistake? What's the relevance of the story?

The mistake of not lynching scum.  The story is relevant because MiX is doing the exact same thing as I did then, as scum.

Wait, what did I do that is similar to this?

vote:joseph

(forgot to bold)

Such a OMGUS vote

Nah, wasn't because it was on me, but because it was jumping the wagon.

Scummmmyyyyy.

That reminds me I need to keep track of reads of this game.

Have we ever lynched Faust day 1 before? Let's try it vote: faust

L a z y and I'm pretty sure it's also a scumtell for mail-mi.

Anyway, mail-mi has come back to thread and posted and ignored my revelation so I guess there's no point waiting around any longer.

The item I need appears in mail-mi's list.

Vote: mail-mi

Probably not leaving there for the rest of the day.

What does that have to do with mail-mi not saying anything? How was he supposed to know he had the doubleclaim?


And after these, there's nothing else. I can't recall anything that anyone has done of any significance other than this 1v1 and Galzria's arguments against this being a 1v1.

Skip's still scum I think.

PPE: Do you have any posts that are scummy for mail-mi?

[skip wooznum]

I buy the argument that skip is scummy for making this a 1v1 but then expects to not be lynched when mail-mi flips town.

Maybe you misunderstood my response? I fully expect to be lynched tomorrow if mail-mi flips town. I'll still try as hard as I can to fight it. But anyway, mail-mi will flip scum.

[MiX]

I buy the argument that skip is scummy for making this a 1v1 but then expects to not be lynched when mail-mi flips town.

Maybe you misunderstood my response? I fully expect to be lynched tomorrow if mail-mi flips town. I'll still try as hard as I can to fight it. But anyway, mail-mi will flip scum.

Okay, how about this. If you're scum, you expect to lynch mail-mi and live. I can see the future, this is what will happen if you're not lynched today.

Also doing this 1v1 as town is bad because mail-mi can easily be town.

Meh, I just don't think you're town. It's hard to explain.

[skip wooznum]

Anyway, mail-mi has come back to thread and posted and ignored my revelation so I guess there's no point waiting around any longer.

The item I need appears in mail-mi's list.

Vote: mail-mi

Probably not leaving there for the rest of the day.

What does that have to do with mail-mi not saying anything? How was he supposed to know he had the doubleclaim?

The vote didn't have to do with him not saying anything. What I meant was that my hopes of getting mail-mi to commit to an opinion on whether or not this was 1v1, before knowing if he was involved, were proving fruitless. Therefore, may as well just vote him already.

[skip wooznum]

I buy the argument that skip is scummy for making this a 1v1 but then expects to not be lynched when mail-mi flips town.

Maybe you misunderstood my response? I fully expect to be lynched tomorrow if mail-mi flips town. I'll still try as hard as I can to fight it. But anyway, mail-mi will flip scum.

Okay, how about this. If you're scum, you expect to lynch mail-mi and live. I can see the future, this is what will happen if you're not lynched today.

Also doing this 1v1 as town is bad because mail-mi can easily be town.

Meh, I just don't think you're town. It's hard to explain.

I'm not sure what to say to this except I have no idea what scum!me would expect, and scum!me would never do this. Neither would scum!you or scum!anybody else in this game, which is why I'm so befuddled as to how anybody thinks I'm scum.

[sudgy]

If joth had less votes I would vote for him, but I don't really think he's scum.

I'm also feeling a bit more comfortable with my MiX vote.  I remember in one RMM game I was in I was scum and had the power to secretly lynch someone when they were at L-1.  At one point someone got to L-2 and I freaked out, saying, "What if scum has the power to lynch early?  We shouldn't get people so close to being lynched!"  I didn't realize it then, but I was freaking out because I was trying to act like town, but I had the information scum has.  Thankfully, they didn't lynch me for it, but I don't want to repeat that mistake here.

I don't follow. What mistake? What's the relevance of the story?

The mistake of not lynching scum.  The story is relevant because MiX is doing the exact same thing as I did then, as scum.

Wait, what did I do that is similar to this?

It was your whole thing of "scum have powers to block, intercept, etc. item transfer".  That's the reason I'm voting for you.

[MiX]

If joth had less votes I would vote for him, but I don't really think he's scum.

I'm also feeling a bit more comfortable with my MiX vote.  I remember in one RMM game I was in I was scum and had the power to secretly lynch someone when they were at L-1.  At one point someone got to L-2 and I freaked out, saying, "What if scum has the power to lynch early?  We shouldn't get people so close to being lynched!"  I didn't realize it then, but I was freaking out because I was trying to act like town, but I had the information scum has.  Thankfully, they didn't lynch me for it, but I don't want to repeat that mistake here.

I don't follow. What mistake? What's the relevance of the story?

The mistake of not lynching scum.  The story is relevant because MiX is doing the exact same thing as I did then, as scum.

Wait, what did I do that is similar to this?

It was your whole thing of "scum have powers to block, intercept, etc. item transfer".  That's the reason I'm voting for you.

Swan said that first. Can you double check?

[Swowl]

If joth had less votes I would vote for him, but I don't really think he's scum.

I'm also feeling a bit more comfortable with my MiX vote.  I remember in one RMM game I was in I was scum and had the power to secretly lynch someone when they were at L-1.  At one point someone got to L-2 and I freaked out, saying, "What if scum has the power to lynch early?  We shouldn't get people so close to being lynched!"  I didn't realize it then, but I was freaking out because I was trying to act like town, but I had the information scum has.  Thankfully, they didn't lynch me for it, but I don't want to repeat that mistake here.

I don't follow. What mistake? What's the relevance of the story?

The mistake of not lynching scum.  The story is relevant because MiX is doing the exact same thing as I did then, as scum.

Wait, what did I do that is similar to this?

It was your whole thing of "scum have powers to block, intercept, etc. item transfer".  That's the reason I'm voting for you.

Swan said that first. Can you double check?

confirmed that was me that brought up that concept.

[LaLight]

what's going on here

Out of skip and mail-mi, I choose to vote mail-mi which I already do.

[faust]

Or, he could have been trying to figure out what he was doing, and was asking for advice?  I feel that especially fits here with skip being suddenly thrown into the game.  A lot of what seems scummy about skip can be explained as "he had little time to think of anything and has been trying to keep up ever since."  Now, between him and mail-mi, I would pick him, but I don't think he is as scummy as people seem to be making him out to be.

You make it sound as though he entered the game suddenly on Day 3. The post where he talked about the double item was well after his entrance into the game.

[faust]

Meh. Vote: maiil-mi

[faust]

Oops.

Vote: mail-mi

[Joseph2302]

I buy the argument that skip is scummy for making this a 1v1 but then expects to not be lynched when mail-mi flips town.

Maybe you misunderstood my response? I fully expect to be lynched tomorrow if mail-mi flips town. I'll still try as hard as I can to fight it. But anyway, mail-mi will flip scum.

Okay, how about this. If you're scum, you expect to lynch mail-mi and live. I can see the future, this is what will happen if you're not lynched today.

Also doing this 1v1 as town is bad because mail-mi can easily be town.

Meh, I just don't think you're town. It's hard to explain.

I think scum would potentially try a 1 v 1, to "hide in plain sight". Because it has worked in games in the past for scum

[sudgy]

If joth had less votes I would vote for him, but I don't really think he's scum.

I'm also feeling a bit more comfortable with my MiX vote.  I remember in one RMM game I was in I was scum and had the power to secretly lynch someone when they were at L-1.  At one point someone got to L-2 and I freaked out, saying, "What if scum has the power to lynch early?  We shouldn't get people so close to being lynched!"  I didn't realize it then, but I was freaking out because I was trying to act like town, but I had the information scum has.  Thankfully, they didn't lynch me for it, but I don't want to repeat that mistake here.

I don't follow. What mistake? What's the relevance of the story?

The mistake of not lynching scum.  The story is relevant because MiX is doing the exact same thing as I did then, as scum.

Wait, what did I do that is similar to this?

It was your whole thing of "scum have powers to block, intercept, etc. item transfer".  That's the reason I'm voting for you.

Swan said that first. Can you double check?

confirmed that was me that brought up that concept.

And looking at it, your post bringing it up had more reason to it, so I guess just Unvote.

If I had to pick between skip and mail-mi, even though skip seems more scummy to me, I would probably go for mail-mi, because skip is at least trying to be helpful.  No offense mail-mi, but don't be surprised if we lynch you because are currently being pretty anti-town.

[MiX]

What did mail-mi do that's so scummy?

This is for everyone.

[jotheonah]

We have about 29 hours until deadline. I think we should try to avoid a panic lynch tomorrow. It’s been a roller coaster of a day, so I’m going to try and do one more re-read this afternoon then commit to a position.

[jotheonah]

What did mail-mi do that's so scummy?

This is for everyone.

Nothing really. He had the same item need as skip and was scummier vis a vis the circumstances of that claim, but outside of that situation, which I’ve come around on, I don’t think there’s much of a case.

[faust]

What did mail-mi do that's so scummy?

This is for everyone.

I think the number of people who were willing to dismiss the one piece of hard evidence that we have as NAI was suspicious. And mail-mi hasn't done anything that scum wouldn't do.

Also I've come around on skip a little, his explanation made sense.

[MiX]

What did mail-mi do that's so scummy?

This is for everyone.

I think the number of people who were willing to dismiss the one piece of hard evidence that we have as NAI was suspicious. And mail-mi hasn't done anything that scum wouldn't do.

Also I've come around on skip a little, his explanation made sense.

I feel like mail-mi loses the 1v1 automatically by virtue of being called mail-mi. This also feels like a plan made by skip, and scum!skip probably loves doing this based on what I've seen of him.

I also confused skip with scolapasta btw, this is coloring my read on him. Skip doesn't have a finished game that I actually read. But the above's about skip.

Too Many Games. Too many. I'll just sheep whatever joth does.

[jotheonah]

MiX: joth is definitely 100% scum and I'm sure of it
also MiX: I'll just sheep whatever joth does

[MiX]

MiX: joth is definitely 100% scum and I'm sure of it
also MiX: I'll just sheep whatever joth does

I was baiting you into townslipping! Obviously.

Wallpost!joth is town!joth, I don't care.

[MiX]

I have to say, I usually love D1s, but in this setup I desperately want to see a night. I also don't have as much motivation for reading and voting as normal, especially with this terrible 1v1 that people think is evidence of anything.

Joth, make your wallpost already, I need to sheep fast so I can look towny by voting scum.