With joth, my suspicion basically boils down to me going 'let's imagine joth is scum. do his posts feel coherent with that?" and concluding that they do. His posts tend to be sensible and lengthy, and are missing the edge that town people who are wrong about stuff tend to have.
Here's an auto-generated voting history (no guarantee that the L-X annotations are correct, though I tried to fix them).
#54: jotheonah votes Robz888 (L-6)
#61: jotheonah votes Jimmmmm (L-5)
#161: jotheonah votes Dylan32 (L-3)
#174: jotheonah votes DatSwan (L-4)
#224: jotheonah votes Jimmmmm (L-6)
#226: jotheonah votes silverspawn (L-4)
#280: jotheonah votes DatSwan (L-4)
#331: jotheonah votes DatSwan (L-3)
#352: jotheonah votes Jimmmmm (L-5)
#356: jotheonah votes DatSwan (L-3)
#386: jotheonah votes Jimmmmm (L-2)
#489: jotheonah votes Galzria (hammer)
#534: jotheonah votes DatSwan (L-5)
#555: jotheonah unvotes
#620: jotheonah votes UmbrageOfSnow (L-4)
#634: jotheonah votes Robz888 (L-3)
This is a nothingburger case that's sort of hard to respond to, but I'll give it a try. I think there are definitely some things I've said and done that aren't consistent with me being scum.
One, why does scum!me hammer Galz? I've already said I was going to bed. I come back in the last few minutes of the day. Does scum!me really risk the heat from essentially quickhammering Galzria when he could achieve a no-lynch, which we had, even at that point, openly established was pro-scum, just by doing nothing? And Galzria in particular was reading me pretty towny and is a good player to have on your side, so it makes even less sense. That was a hard decision to make as town, but I can't see any explanation for me making it as scum.
The edge thing sounds like a gut read. I haven't been holding back. I have been trying to stay cognizant of my tendency to tunnel and trying to keep an open mind, so maybe that has made my posts less "edgy".
So Dylan has a bunch of things that I think are more likely to come from town than scum. One is his treatments of the masons, first throwing suspicion then just now saying faust's narrative has been sorta convincing. Difficult to imagine scum who knows it's true from the start handling it that way.
Both Robz and I basically treated the Mason claim exactly the same way, first throwing suspicion and then coming around to it because of faust's claim. Weird that that's super towny for Dylan and not worth noting for Robz or me. It could just as easily be scum coming into the day thinking they could push a mason lynch through and then backing off when it looked like it wasn't working. I don't think it is that, because I know I'm not scum, but I don't think it's a town tell. It's null.