(Ignoring anything happening now and decide to post it, in case it is still useful.)
Has anyone, perchance, looked at the mafiascum plays of this setup to see how they handled the Doctor claiming/not claiming? And how that worked out for them? I haven't had time, but I know multiple games are linked in the wiki entry for Fire and Ice.
Finished skimming a game yesterday to see if I can learn any useful, before you even asked, but didn't post it because of its uselessness.
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=52&t=17571 (open 309)
They jump into scum hunt pretty soon (without any theory talk) and then the doctor is killed N1 (with no apparent PR slip), so it seems that it is not so helpful in our current situation. In the end the town have a lucky win.
Has anyone, perchance, looked at the mafiascum plays of this setup to see how they handled the Doctor claiming/not claiming? And how that worked out for them? I haven't had time, but I know multiple games are linked in the wiki entry for Fire and Ice.
reading those games is horrible. Like headache inducing horrible...
the one game I just glanced through (town win) didn't discuss it. One player seems to have been very against it and the town doc was killed night3 (having a successful protection night2). ice and fire shot each other to give town the win...
I guess we were looking at the same one?
----------------------------------
I just found this one though,
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=52&t=22902 (open434)
An ice mafia fake claimed doc D1, and the real doctor only counterclaim D2. Town lost in the end.
In case you want to know where to find more games:
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Fire_and_Ice#HistoryI understand that I =am the one who have the least post apart from NHS, whose is a new player and I can complete understand that. I am trying to catch up with everything right now, although on my first glance it seems that everything I would like to talk about after think for an entire day have already been said, I would try to express what I think and additionally see if I can add any contribution soon.