Commenting as I go through the game. I was vaguely following D1, Dylan got mislynched right ? I guess I'll see soon enough. I apologize in advance for the wall of text.
Vote: Dylan
Vote: Dylan
Super early, but still, gonna say Andrew and faust are somewhat unlikely to be scum together.
Early Skumpy is very reminiscent of M105!Skumpy.
#96: e being self-aware, hm.
#102: towny chairs, to the point.
Awaclus has an awful neighborizer plan which seems out-of-character.
#126: I know, right ? (not alignment-relevant, don't bother)
#127: IDPTG's "Skumpy covered the setup pretty well" seems scummy to me. I seem to remember IDPTG being more interested in setup talk than that.
#136: Galz arbitratily declaring faust is town. Townie. Also accurately calls out IDPTG for talking about rereads for a game that's barely started.
#140: Nevermind, e is town again.
#153: A bad IDPTG vote (on Andrew, who was doing fine). Well, I know who I'd have been wanting to lynch at that point.
faust is having some fun. I don't remember what that means, but I like it.
Dylan wagon forming because LALL. Ugh. People, you need to stop listening to faust on D1, lynching lurkers suck. I would never support such a thing. Never !
#169: Oh no, I unwittingly agreed with Awaclus, argh.
#175: A well-deserved vote for faust by Awaclus. What is happening ?
#176: IDPTG making sense, which I think is townie for him. I guess I'd be switching to... well, not faust I don't think, but someone else at this point. Maybe Swan.
#180: Galz doing some Awaclus-wrangling. Easy to fake (unhelpful town is lovely to deal with as scum, not that Awaclus was being particularly unhelpful here but you know), but I like it.
#189: Of course faust hates it (it being the above).
#193: Yeah, IDPTG is getting townie now (nothing super specific, just generally being constructive).
#194: Aaaaaand Galz getting into a theoretical argument with Awaclus AND voting for "me". Sigh. You were doing so well !
#198: More alignment-irrelevant truth from Andrew.
Andrew is funny. I missed playing with you, it's been a while !
Ah, Space is in this game. Yeah, I guess that's where my vote would've been at that point. I do think I have a math-hating bias against them, but oh well.
#216: Wait wait, Space is actually giving reads, real ones. Nevermind then. That's atually a super-townie post given that scum!Space was entirely incapable of doing even half of that in M108.
#236: e oppoing up again to say not much, which reminds me he should have been more of a presence. Town points from earlier are officially rescinded.
#245: Skumpy going from a non-wagon to another, which at this exact point of the game is townie I think. Also... yeah, Dylan did get mislynched (and I see Galz was killed too, I guess I can stop commenting on him) and was the leading wagon at this point, yet Raptor has nothing to say about him. Given that Dylan was town, I find that super-townie: scum definitely wants to take some sort of stance regarding a leading mislynch wagon.
#251: Don't like that Swan vote, and not just because it's on "me". Feels forced, with some scummy hedge too.
#256: Dead town reads! Unvoting scummy!Swan to vote for "me". Tssk.
#265: "X is town." posts are my favorite posts. Still not convinced Swan is though. I was also just thinking I had no idea how I could read XXR, so I'm very curious what made Swan think that, especially given the triplets-claim . Swan ?
#284: A wild gkrieg appears ! He's doing a reread right away, doesn't he know only losers do that ?
It's actually a pretty good post. I think scum!gkrieg is the constructive type, though ? Don't remember if I've encountered scum!gkrieg past his newbie days.
Awaclus is funny too, sometimes.
#300: A wild e re-appears ! Self-aware again. Weird. Maybe scummy, especially because there's no follow-up to "I sure haven't been doing much this game !". Paraphrasing.
#313: IDPTG u Andrew(2), v Raptor (1)
This is a pretty interesting point wagon-wise btw. Vote count there is
Space (3): gkrieg, Swan, ANdrew
Andrew (3): IDPTG, Space, Skumpy
LL (2): Galz, Dylan
Dylan (2): faust, LL
faust (2): Raptor, Awaclus
IDPTG (1): e
Seems pretty safe to bet at least one scum has 2 votes on them. Otherwise they're sitting pretty I suppose, but I'd expect the people doing the most work at this point to be more likely to be scum.
faust is there but that's just faust, mostly I'm looking at IDPTG's #309 vote and especially DatSwan's #331 vote. They both are getting off the leading wagons (Andrew and Space) and Swan's Dylan vote makes him the lead lynch candidate.
Andrew's 334 also fit, but like IDPTG he goes to a new wagon, so Swan still looks scummiest here.
#349: More of e saying "oh noes I'm not doing anything that's bad" and still not doing anything. I do not care for it, at all.
#354: Kinda smarmy from Swan, scummy I think.
Ah, Swan's #356 kinda ruins my argument (going back to Andrew, resulting in
faust (3) Raptor, Awaclus, Dylan
Andrew (3): Space, Skumpy, Swan
Dylan (2): faust, LL
LL (1): Galz
IDPTG (1): e
Raptor (1): IDPTG
Space (1): gkrieg
Swan (1): Andrew
Oh well, he's still scummy. I do think this vote count also makes faust and Andrew scummy based on how the day ended up (but I could be proved wrong by how things go from there again I guess). That is, I'm assuming there to be some effort to swing towards Dylan next if one of them is scum.
IDPTG goes for a Raptor lurker thing rather than Dylan, which looks townie given Dylan's alignment.
And then he ruins it with a scumslip argument. Boo !
8 hours to deadline at this point, things are veeery undecided. Scum has to be worried, even if they're not in the main three "wagons" (faust, Andrew, Dylan), this a very indecisive D1 and scum does not like that.
And the first swing vote I was waiting for on Dylan comes from... Galz (426). Of course. Hrmph.
Townpoints to Swan for defending Dylan here. Even if the main three wagons are on town, I think scum is still nervous and wants nothing more than let the Dylan momentum continue. I mean, both faust and Galz are now on him, that's a very good start, but at only three votes anything could still happen.
#441: Here's the scummy swing vote I was looking for, by Andrew. A bit of a fussy vote too, especially for ANdrew.
#449: With Awaclus on Andrew, it's now looking like a Dylan v Andrew thing. ANdrew gets to L-2 first thanks to gkrieg (#455), but then Skumpy switches, which is pretty decisive and does not look good for Skumpy. Unless Andrew is town, in which case whatever, scum is fine sitting back now, they're safe.
e still trying to lynch IDPTG at this point ? Ugh.
#490: Skumpy unvoting ! Definitely not Andrew's partner then, which might be useful to know later.
#530: e finally accepting that it's Andrew v Dylan, picks Dylan. Definitely doesn't feel partner-y to Andrew either, but fits the bill of scum being present to ensure a lynch goes through and trying to play truthtfully in the meantime. It's a very strange move for town!e to try for an IDPTG wagon for so long here.
Null on Raptor's hammer. It's not great because Dylan could have claimed, but I entirely buy that Raptor didn't realize it and it was very close to deadline. Don't think it's alignment-indicatve at all really.
Done for now. e is the scummiest player in the game by a fair margin so far.