K. Checking in again.
Couple things I've noticed/want to respond to.
I have not read M7, Frisk, so no need to point fingers
I agree with Jorbles, that it is not so obvious that newbish scum would be most afraid of experienced town. In fact, upon reflection, I think it's quite the opposite. An experienced scum has played other games with the experienced player, who probably knows their playstyle. Also, being the only experienced player increases ones power in the game. Do you notice how we (the newbs) have been relying on Eevee, O, Robz, and Frisk to provide us with information about previous games and general information about how the game works? Well two of those people are gone now, increasing how much the other two can steer the town.
I agree that we would have been unlikely to lynch O. Despite his hardcore tunneling on a towny, I think many of us would have reasoned that it would be just too crazy a thing for scum or PR to do, which means we would have treated him as semi-confirmed VT. That's actually what surprises me most about the O NK, is that almost everyone who'd read him said he was probably VT, which means the scum either a) didn't notice these reads b) decided O was worth killing even though he was unlikely to be a PR c) thought that semi-confirmed VT was a more powerful asset to town than a PR d) Thought O had so much chutzpah that he would play like that as a PR
As much as I like Eevee's congeniality, he has already encouraged us not to base our reads off of personality, and I don't want to let this get buried. After I accused Eevee in my post 'o quotes, he congratulated me on suspecting him, in a sort of win-over-with-flattery type way and then moves on. I want to know what you guys think about it, and make sure it doesn't get buried.
@GeoLib
Haha, obviously no one is going to get lynched before tomorrow. I don't really know how to address your case since.. yeah, those quotes are from me? I believe I was pretty spot on with Robz and in the end finally realized it was not a smart lynch, but it was too late. I stand by everything I said about him yesterday though Actually, props to you for suspecting me because I actually agree my yesterday's end game behavior could easily be interpreted as scummy. Hopefully you'll remember my earlier stuff too and that will clear me some!
Coupled with my realization that eliminating O gives the other experienced players more sway, I think Eevee looks suspicious.
Next. I agree with Captain Frisk and Eevee about role claims.
Doctor should not claim unless it is the only way to prevent his lynch (or perhaps to out scum fake-claim. Is that worth it?)
Cop should claim on two scum investigations immediately. Should try to steer town in the direction of one and claim if necessary. Should try to steer town away from investigated townies.
Am I correct that cop only gets alignment and not role? Should tell us investigation results as reads somewhere in thread not too obvious, so that when he flips we get his info.
Jailkeeper is tough... Regardless. At present the jailer obviously doesn't have any information.
I agree it seems unlikely that Robz would get lynched with 0 scum on the wagon. Also, if I were scum, I would probably make sure that we weren't both on the wagon, but a newbie scum might have made a mistake, so we should bear that in mind.
Morgrim!! I don't care if you're upset about being VT. Over half of the people in this game were VT and all of us are playing normally. Post something other than repeated your VT claim or I will tunnel you harder than O tunneled Robz. I still sort of think we should lynch Morgrim actually. I'm still with Robz that this seems like he's playing the "crazy Morgrim" role because this is just ridiculous.
Speaking of over half VT, we are now two down, plus two scum, plus one mafia rolecop investigee. With some quick and dirty math (I can write it out if you guys care):
Even if we scum-lynch or no-lynch, there is a 55% chance that the scum will hit a PR tomorrow with their NK.
If we lynch VT, then it's a 63% chance.
If we lynch a PR then well, that's a 100% that we'll have a dead PR.
I just think we should bear in mind that we'll likely lose a PR soon.
On the bright side, if I pick one of you at random and tunnel hardcore, there's a 1/3 chance you're scum!
That's all from me for now. I really have stuff to do and will maybe post here one more time today. If not I will be back to post on Wednesday eastern time, probably in the evening.