I'm not quite sure when my play isn't erratic; panicy is some nice flavor text you added. I do not think any theory involving me as mafia is "crackpot" (though of course I know them false), just this 3-out-of-4 Bombshell by Robz. Mostly because if we followed it I believe the town has a chance of losing pretty quickly: Lynch grujah, and if he's town: Lynch Galz/O as per Robz theory, I'm town/Galz probably is town, and then because of people like Tables/SFS lynch the other "partner", and oh look, he's town and we're at 3 misslynches because of one theory.
From what I understood of what Robz said, he doesn't think there are 3/4 mafia on the bandwagon. We don't even know if there are 3 mafia. What Robz said was (I'm paraphrasing here) that there's probably 2 mafia on it. And there's no reason we should, or even would, blindly follow such a strategy all the way through. It makes good odds for a lynch, and after that we have new information; we look back, re-evaluate what we know, see if it still makes sense and move forward.
If it was a single small mistake, why did you immediately vote for me?
Are you completely ignoring the fact I pegged you as one of my strongest suspicions in the immediately preceeding post, and even put a bolded FOS on you?
Honestly, I can smell the troll-bait. At the VERY least I provided a link to Talihandur's tells, which is more than you've done.
Troll bait? And yet you're the one whose just started throwing insults around. This is I believe the second thing you've quoted at me as things you've done, and once again it's a link to information. In fact, just a link to one guy's tells that he uses. IIoA. I have nothing recorded in my notes that's That doesn't mean you said nothing, just that nothing you've said was interesting or useful enough for me to make a note you said it. Perhaps saying you've contributed nothing was an exaggeration. Perhaps 'almost nothing noteworthy' would be more accurate. The only good thing I have by your name is trying to call Theorel's posts as a pre-lynch cover, and that wasn't even correct (but you knew that at the time, more than likely...).
I feel the need in most games to respond to every vote against me, but since this one is so clearly personal instead of scumhunting I'm pretty sure I can just ignore it after this post.
When did I say a single personal thing? If you didn't want to be accused of contributing virtually nothing and posting IIoA, you shouldn't have contributed virtually nothing and shouldn't have posted IIoA. You're the one who seems to use Ad Hominem's and try to avoid arguing against the facts presented (Except by strawman) when a case is presented.
Anyway this argument now looks pointless as having read beyond this reply, I see you probably won't read this until day 3 (if you're still alive).
For me, my lynch preferences would be, all in order:
O, Joth, (Pops, Grujah)
I'd be less willing, but not overly upset with a lynch of:
Glooble, Axxle2, DSell, Frisk
O I think should be obvious, from this post. Joth's play I've found continually scummy, for reasons given at various times. Pops I've also laid out a case against, but his discussion with Galz has made me less suspicious. Grujah I think we could get a lot of information from, by looking at todays bandwagon and other things he's done. And while Robz is I think likely town and his theory likely correct, I'm happy to accept it might be wrong, and Grujah might just be a mafia who got saved by a lucky break.
Glooble's twinclaim makes him interesting - I'm not overly suspicious but think we could gain something from it. Axxle2's said nothing remarkable in my opinion, and Green Opal too, and neither have rubbed me as especially town or mafia. DSell I have very little information on, although he's said a few good things. Frisk is interesting, he's posted some good analysis but also some posts which just seem like long accounts of information (e.g. 2078).
Missing are Robz, Galz and SFS. SFS I think is likely town, as I've said before (but don't think he's almost certainly town!). Robz and Galz I'm not convinced are town any more than the people from DSell down, but their activity is good, and I think that the cost of mislynching either could be too much.
Author
Topic: Mafia IV: Within These Estate Walls (GAME OVER - MAFIA WINS!) (Read 338157 times)