I wish i read all that backwards... would of been way faster.
I only get what is happening based on reading these convos so i wanna make sure i have everything straight...
1) Galz and Joth are ICs and Masons
2) Eddie is (assuming town) Maggie, and it seems that is a feasible thing based on Galz explanation when combined with ADK claim.
3) ADK is claimed survivor with a Vig shot
4) MiX is cleared by Galz as town barring some GF ability/item/etc.
I think that all checks out yes?
Ok here is the issue i am having with all this being true... keeping in mind i actually believe most of it, so if someone wants to throw some cents in that would be rad.
Here is Day 1 Final VC:
Day 1 Final Vote Count:
MiX (1): shraeye
EFHW (9): Galzria, WCD, Datswan, Awaclus, joth, Space, Glooble, MiX, 2.7
Galzria (1) EFHW
WCD (1): pubby
joth (3): ADK, faust, Uncle
faust (1): PPS
Not Voting (0):
With 16 alive, it took 9 to lynch. Day 1 ended at 6:00 a.m. on July 31.
So what... skum just wasn’t playing wasn’t playing defense end of day 1?
If we assume ADK is survivor and Eddie is town, this essentially means that skum literally did nothing to create a viable defense for EFHW in the end. [Shraeye, Pubby, PPS, Faust] were the 4 off wagoners... and they were all on different wagons.
So if the town calls (or town/survivor calls i should say) are correct, we essentially have to choose between:
A) Skum being off wagon and not wanting to consolidate even at the expense of loosing EFHW.
- this theory pretty much means it would be exactly (assuming 4 skum) [1 on Joth, 1 bussing, 1 off, and EFHW].
- So the busier and the off wagoner could of moved to the same wagon to swing it... but that would look super bad vca wise so i can see how this theory pans out.
- This would put the skum buckets as:
1 On Wagon [WCD, Swan, Awaclus, Space, Glooble]
1 Joth Wagon [Faust]
1 Off Wagons [Shraeye, Pubby, PPS]
B) Skum was double bussing Day 1 with another on Joth
- so the buckets would be:
2 in [WCD, Swan, Awaclus, Space, Glooble]
1 in [Faust]
C) Skum scattered, but none on Joth.
- Almost impossible IMO, would mean that skum did not try to play D at all. But it would assuredly be something like this for buckets:
2 in [WCD, Swan, Awaclus, Space, Glooble]
1 in [Shraeye, Pubby, PPS]
I am leaning pretty heavy on A.
So pretty much...
if ADK and Eddie are both telling the truth - Faust looks super suspicious... but then 1 of the other skum is still in the [Shraeye, Pubby, PPS] pool.
If one of them are lying, it could still be Faust, but more likely one in [Shraeye, Pubby, PPS].
As we are not going to have a super conclusive result on the town nature of ADK and Eddie right now... i think Shraeye, Pubby, PPS is a good place to look for now.
PPE E getting shot.