Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

I mean too powerful

Really? I think it's fairly weaksauce. Host/human knowledge doesn't help us catch scum.

[A Drowned Kernel]

I don't think ADK's claim makes a ton of sense flavor-wise.

I don't know a lot about the flavor but that's my role. The ability name is "greet newcomers", does that make it make any more sense?

Also the self-preservation argument is bullshit given that you're a host.

Yes because being dead and not able to use my power or vote isn't important at all

[A Drowned Kernel]

ADK - your claim:

you try to track someone; if they're a host you see who they targeted? And nothing if they're human? How do you know if no results are they are human vs they're not targeting someone vs being blocked?

I get a positive result on whether they're human or host, but I only get the tracking if they're a host

so you're flavor cop AND Tracker? Given my role I don't think it's possible for town to have those roles.

"Host or human" is a far cry from flavor cop

[scolapasta]

One issue I see in exiling ADK is if they are a host (seemed fairly likely that claim is true?) then we still remain in doubt about whether they are scum or not.

That feels like it plays to scum's favor. Exile and kill hosts (which they know are not on their team, but we do not).

[mail-mi]

Here's one more thing to think about: Scum having a host/human cop would be very useful to them, so they can find who they can actually kill.

ADK, do you have any more powers?

[A Drowned Kernel]

Here's one more thing to think about: Scum having a host/human cop would be very useful to them, so they can find who they can actually kill.

ADK, do you have any more powers?

I do have maintenance but that's it

How much does scum actually care about killing humans vs. hosts? Hosts can be revived but maintenance takes a long time and requires the dead hosts to correctly pick town humans

[scolapasta]

Here's one more thing to think about: Scum having a host/human cop would be very useful to them, so they can find who they can actually kill.

ADK, do you have any more powers?

True, this related to what I posted. Having this power would help scum in the effectiveness of their NKs.

I mean if there is a scum host (and there must be, right?), it'll be tough to exile them, but exile them we must.

[faust]

I don't think ADK's claim makes a ton of sense flavor-wise.

I don't know a lot about the flavor but that's my role. The ability name is "greet newcomers", does that make it make any more sense?

Less, actually. The newcomers are the humans, so if the power was named like that it would make more sense for it to do stuff to humans.

I mean, my powers aren't all that flavorful either, but this seems like a particularly ill fit.

[mail-mi]

Here's one more thing to think about: Scum having a host/human cop would be very useful to them, so they can find who they can actually kill.

ADK, do you have any more powers?

I do have maintenance but that's it

How much does scum actually care about killing humans vs. hosts? Hosts can be revived but maintenance takes a long time and requires the dead hosts to correctly pick town humans

I guess they may not care, but it would still be a useful power for them. Especially if they have powers that only work on hosts/humans, like you.

[mail-mi]

I don't want another end of day Europe scramble like yesterday. I think we're likely to hit a scum host here anyway.

Vote: ADK

[scolapasta]

I don't want another end of day Europe scramble like yesterday. I think we're likely to hit a scum host here anyway.

Vote: ADK

That's the hammer, right?

I agree there's a good chance of scum here, I'm just concerned we won't know. I guess it'll be interesting for whatever human ADK contacts...

[scolapasta]

I don't want another end of day Europe scramble like yesterday. I think we're likely to hit a scum host here anyway.

Vote: ADK

That's the hammer, right?

I agree there's a good chance of scum here, I'm just concerned we won't know. I guess it'll be interesting for whatever human ADK contacts...

Though the "I don't want another end of day Europe scramble like yesterday" is a little weird. It's still only 11am forum time, i.e USA East time, so way plenty of time before we get to European scrambled.

[mail-mi]

I don't want another end of day Europe scramble like yesterday. I think we're likely to hit a scum host here anyway.

Vote: ADK

That's the hammer, right?

I agree there's a good chance of scum here, I'm just concerned we won't know. I guess it'll be interesting for whatever human ADK contacts...

I think so.

[MiX]

Hammer's anti town. Why did we kill a scum tracker? It's not like they're not getting revived.

It's fine to be honest. I just wish ADK was worse as scum.

Can you maintenence this night?

[mail-mi]

Hammer's anti town. Why did we kill a scum tracker? It's not like they're not getting revived.

It's fine to be honest. I just wish ADK was worse as scum.

Can you maintenence this night?

uh, that would be why I hammered. Also not wanting another horrible EoD like D1

[MiX]

What do we gain from roleblocking a scum tracker?

You know what, faust was right. Exiling is wrong.

I wish I was here to unvote when ADK claimed host.

[A Drowned Kernel]

Hammer's anti town. Why did we kill a scum tracker? It's not like they're not getting revived.

It's fine to be honest. I just wish ADK was worse as scum.

Can you maintenence this night?

I can maitenance tomorrow, because that's how maitenance works

[faust]

Hammer's anti town. Why did we kill a scum tracker? It's not like they're not getting revived.

Well I doubt that claim was truthful.

[MiX]

Hammer's anti town. Why did we kill a scum tracker? It's not like they're not getting revived.

Well I doubt that claim was truthful.

Do you think ADK's not a tracker and flavor cop?

[WestCoastDidds]

Ugh.

This will be the least helpful flip ever if ADK is a host.

[WestCoastDidds]

It also feels a lot like faust and scola were engineering this with yams, and that feels pretty scummilicous to me.  I am still a bit mystified about the hammer with so much of the day remaining and so few people around at the time.

[scolapasta]

It also feels a lot like faust and scola were engineering this with yams, and that feels pretty scummilicous to me.  I am still a bit mystified about the hammer with so much of the day remaining and so few people around at the time.

Funny you think I may have engineered this when I made both the points you made:
• ADK being host is not very helpful
• hammer when so much of day is remaining

[mail-mi]

It also feels a lot like faust and scola were engineering this with yams, and that feels pretty scummilicous to me.  I am still a bit mystified about the hammer with so much of the day remaining and so few people around at the time.

"So much of the day remaining"? There was less than 24 hours, and I didn't want another EoD like day 1. I think ADK was scummy and it was a good enough exile for me.

Also, we're never going to just lynch humans. We have to lynch hosts at some point because I'm 100% sure there's at least 1 scum host.

[mail-mi]

It also feels a lot like faust and scola were engineering this with yams, and that feels pretty scummilicous to me.  I am still a bit mystified about the hammer with so much of the day remaining and so few people around at the time.

"So much of the day remaining"? There was less than 24 hours, and I didn't want another EoD like day 1. I think ADK was scummy and it was a good enough exile for me.

Also, we're never going to just lynch humans. We have to lynch hosts at some point because I'm 100% sure there's at least 1 scum host.

*Exile, woops

[faust]

Hammer's anti town. Why did we kill a scum tracker? It's not like they're not getting revived.

Well I doubt that claim was truthful.

Do you think ADK's not a tracker and flavor cop?

Yes, I think he's not a Tracker.