Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Witherweaver]

e, you explained the Haddock vote, but what makes Joseph scummy?

They're scum partners and he needs to build some bus cred, obviously!

[Haddock]

Come to think of it, Joseph jumping on e on the back of the `massclaim incident' (as it shall henceforth be known) is not terrible, but it looks really bad that he then swings round on me as soon as e says anything at all about it.

vote: Joseph

and I will make that a real vote as soon as I check that I'm not hammering or anything.  Small games are WEIRD!

[Witherweaver]

Come to think of it, Joseph jumping on e on the back of the `massclaim incident' (as it shall henceforth be known) is not terrible, but it looks really bad that he then swings round on me as soon as e says anything at all about it.

vote: Joseph

and I will make that a real vote as soon as I check that I'm not hammering or anything.  Small games are WEIRD!

That's interesting, and it also seems to apply symmetrically to you.

[Haddock]

Yeah not even close, vote: Joseph.
It bugs me that I'm agreeing with Awaclus, just on principle.  But meh.

PPE. How so?

[Witherweaver]

Because you jumped on e because of the massclaim incident, backed off when challenged, and are now swinging around to Joseph.

[Witherweaver]

Well, difference is that you initiated the e thing, I think.

[Haddock]

Bah, words. 

I mean:
On principle, it bugs me that I'm agreeing with Awa.

Obviously I'm not saying that I'm agreeing with Awa on principle, which I guess you could read my previous post like that.

PPE. "The massclaim incident" I was talking about was just my mistaken reaction to it.  But yeah ok just terminology.
To your point: Me thinking e wanted a massclaim was a contributing factor but not my only reason to find e scummy.
But yeah OK I can kinda see your point.  The (PPE2: OK, aNOTHER) difference is that I have explained the narrative for my decisions and I hope everyone agrees there's a decent town narrative there.  We have nothing from Joseph.  Yet.

[iguanaiguana]

I think Joseph is town.

[Witherweaver]

I think Joseph is town.

Why is that?

[iguanaiguana]

I think Joseph is town.

Why is that?

Seems likes he's paying about 5% attention to what's going on. Scum usually pays at least like 50% attention because they really don't want to die.

[iguanaiguana]

Hydrad should vote for someone. His claim was really solid.

[iguanaiguana]

Hydrad is like "Yuma in Marvel Heroes Mafia" level IC, meaning that everyone is going to give me all kinds of crap for acting like he's an IC when he totally is.

[ashersky]

Agreeing with awa is scummy.

Sorry, been a busy two days.  Back in full force soon.

[Haddock]

I think Joseph is town.

Why is that?

Seems likes he's paying about 5% attention to what's going on. Scum usually pays at least like 50% attention because they really don't want to die.

Interesting.
He was SK in Harry Potter Mafia, wasn't he?  I know SK behaviour =/= scum behaviour, but I do seem to remember him being pretty unfocused then as well until right at the end - I'll have to go look, though, don't quote me on that.

[Witherweaver]

I'm mostly just not sure scum jumps out ahead with an early VT claim.  Possibly he'd think it would get town cred.

[Awaclus]

Agreeing with awa is scummy.

Why?

[iguanaiguana]

I'm mostly just not sure scum jumps out ahead with an early VT claim.  Possibly he'd think it would get town cred.

That's the thing. As town it's careless but as scum it's actually kinda ballsy and proactive.

[ashersky]

Agreeing with awa is scummy.

Why?

Because you never post your thoughts in thread, so if someone agrees with you, they are more likely to have learned your thoughts in your shared scum QT.

[Awaclus]

Agreeing with awa is scummy.

Why?

Because you never post your thoughts in thread, so if someone agrees with you, they are more likely to have learned your thoughts in your shared scum QT.

Yeah because the scum team is like 4 people and somehow it's also been possible to discuss Joseph's VT claim in response to your proposed plan in a scum QT today.

I post my votes in the thread, you don't have to know the reasons why I think someone is scum to agree with the conclusion.

[ashersky]

Agreeing with awa is scummy.

Why?

Because you never post your thoughts in thread, so if someone agrees with you, they are more likely to have learned your thoughts in your shared scum QT.

Yeah because the scum team is like 4 people and somehow it's also been possible to discuss Joseph's VT claim in response to your proposed plan in a scum QT today.

I post my votes in the thread, you don't have to know the reasons why I think someone is scum to agree with the conclusion.

Hey man, no need to get so defensive (about being caught).

You asked why agreeing with you is scummy -- I gave you a reason.  Doesn't mean I'm right.

(I am.)

[Awaclus]

Hey man, no need to get so defensive (about being caught).

You asked why agreeing with you is scummy -- I gave you a reason.  Doesn't mean I'm right.

(I am.)

So you seriously think that the scum team is like 4 people and somehow it's also been possible to discuss Joseph's VT claim in response to your proposed plan in a scum QT today?

[Roadrunner7671]

"I used to listen to the soap operas with my grandmother." -Bob Edwards

Vote Count 1.2

2.7 (1): Iguanaiguana
WW (1): Ashersky
Joseph2302 (2): Awaclus, Haddock
Awaclus (1): WW
Iguanaiguana (1): ss
Haddock (2): 2.7, Joseph2302

Not voting (1): Hydrad

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

Day1 will end February 19 at 6:00 Pm 

[Joseph2302]

Hey man, no need to get so defensive (about being caught).

You asked why agreeing with you is scummy -- I gave you a reason.  Doesn't mean I'm right.

(I am.)

So you seriously think that the scum team is like 4 people and somehow it's also been possible to discuss Joseph's VT claim in response to your proposed plan in a scum QT today?

Yh this is a non-starter really.
It requires 4 scum people, in which case this game is already wildly imbalanced (as a D1 mislynch would lose the game).

[Hydrad]

hey I'm still here!

And i don't really know who I want to vote though...

[Hydrad]

although I think I'm feeling townish on iguana.