Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ashersky]

I'm sure that munch could have NKed me if he wanted to.

Oh, and this supports me not being MU. if I was MU then I shot munch and raerae. pretty dumb huh?

We're arguing that you are Maquis, Munch and Glooble's partner.

[liopoil]

there is a less than 25% chance that it is even POSSIBLE for me to be maquis. 50-50 chance that theorel is maquis cop. as I showed before, less that 50-50 chance that there is a third maquis. put those together and you get less than 25% chance of it being possible that I am scum.

[theorel]

obviously I'm the MU cop, since ash is voting for liopoil as Maquis.

I think liopoil is a bad lynch idea for today...I'll post more this evening.

Good claim order:
yuma
Dsell
Jimmmm

Then ash should claim his targets.

[liopoil]

I don't understand why ash voting for me makes you the MU cop, but anyway that brings it down to less than 50% chance of it being possible that I'm scum. This is better than every other player in the game except jimmmmm and theorel.

[ashersky]

I don't understand why ash voting for me makes you the MU cop, but anyway that brings it down to less than 50% chance of it being possible that I'm scum. This is better than every other player in the game except jimmmmm and theorel.

Because Theo cleared you of his scum investigations.  And I said I think you are Maquis based on our cases.

[liopoil]

oh, and you knew which cop theorel is... got it

[ashersky]

obviously I'm the MU cop, since ash is voting for liopoil as Maquis.

I think liopoil is a bad lynch idea for today...I'll post more this evening.

Good claim order:
yuma
Dsell
Jimmmm

Then ash should claim his targets.

I guess I understand Theo's concern.  It's going to be "easier" to catch MU than Maquis at this point.  But I think my case on lio is strong.

[Robz888]

The case on lio is super strong.

However, if theorel says Jimm isn't MU... I tend to suspect mcmcsalot the most of being MU. Of course this flies in the face of the only theory I've had so far--which is that mcmc is unlikely to be Galzria's partner.

There's no longer any reason for the claim to not proceed, also. Since we know which cop is which, we might as well know ash's targets so far in case he dies tonight.

[ashersky]

The case on lio is super strong.

However, if theorel says Jimm isn't MU... I tend to suspect mcmcsalot the most of being MU. Of course this flies in the face of the only theory I've had so far--which is that mcmc is unlikely to be Galzria's partner.

There's no longer any reason for the claim to not proceed, also. Since we know which cop is which, we might as well know ash's targets so far in case he dies tonight.

Unforunately, no one is left alive.  Here's my list, and reasoning.

Night 1: raerae.  Not Maqius.  Reason: my top scum read (as you all well knew)
Night 2: Theorel.  Not Maqius.  Reason: top town read for a number of folks, and I never trust that.
Night 3: TheMunch.  Maquis.  (Finally got one right!  And he died.)  Reason: I was pretty certain Glooble's partner had to be off-wagon.  I was looking at the lio wagon originally, but really felt that TheMunch was odd for not contributing, not taking a stand, and for some reason NOT joining the lio wagon.  I figured it was to gain the "well, if I was Glooble's partner, I would have tried to get lio lynched" argument.

After Night 2, I was beginning to think we had no Maquis in the game.  So I was happy when Glooble flipped Maquis.

So, feel free to now say "ash could be the MU-aligned Maquis cop, since he's claiming to have targetted dead people."

I'm not, but understand that argument.  Like I also said, I'm willing to be tomorrow's pre-determined lynch.  It's a waste of Theo's power to check me.

[yuma]

I am a 1-shot Lightning Rod. I have not yet used my power because I think it is a negative utility to town. Yes it would prevent one less death at night, but thus far that would have been bad because we have had scum dying at night, but more importantly it would effectively cause both cop investigations to be nullified. I doubt I will be using it this game because of this... so it is a pretty weak power role. But joth did say that some roles would have a negative utility.

[Dsell]

I was Jadzia Dax, I am now Ezri Dax.

[ashersky]

I was Jadzia Dax, I am now Ezri Dax.

So we're married.  Huh.

[Robz888]

Oh, I am Kasidy Yates, if for some reason that matters.

[Dsell]

What that means, clearly, is that Munch's team tried to kill me last night. My 1-shot deathproof is gone and I'm now a VT.

[ashersky]

What that means, clearly, is that Munch's team tried to kill me last night. My 1-shot deathproof is gone and I'm now a VT.

Doesn't clear you from being MU, though.

[ashersky]

Updated Living:

1. ashersky - Maquis Cop/Worf
2. Robz - Tracker/Kasida Yates
3. yuma - 1-shot Lightning Rod/??
9. liopoil - Neighbor/Rom (Confirmed NOT MU)
10. mcmcsalot   - Bomb/??
11. Jimmmmm - ??/?? (Confirmed NOT MU)
12. theorel - MU Cop/?? (Confirmed Town)
14. Dsell - 1-Shot Deathproof/Jadzia-->Ezri Dax

[mcmcsalot]

I'm general martok, also does anyone oppose the liopoil lynch at this point?

[Robz888]

I'm general martok, also does anyone oppose the liopoil lynch at this point?

theorel does

[ashersky]

Updated Living:

1. ashersky - Maquis Cop/Worf
2. Robz - Tracker/Kasida Yates
3. yuma - 1-shot Lightning Rod/??
9. liopoil - Neighbor/Rom (Confirmed NOT MU)
10. mcmcsalot   - Bomb/General Martok
11. Jimmmmm - ??/?? (Confirmed NOT MU)
12. theorel - MU Cop/?? (Confirmed Town)
14. Dsell - 1-Shot Deathproof/Jadzia-->Ezri Dax

[yuma]

o and I am Elim Garak?

[ashersky]

We need name and role from Jimmmmm, name from yuma, and name from Theo and we're done.

PPE - thanks yuma.

[ashersky]

Updated Living:

1. ashersky - Maquis Cop/Worf
2. Robz - Tracker/Kasida Yates
3. yuma - 1-shot Lightning Rod/Elim Garak
9. liopoil - Neighbor/Rom (Confirmed NOT MU)
10. mcmcsalot   - Bomb/General Martok
11. Jimmmmm - ??/?? (Confirmed NOT MU)
12. theorel - MU Cop/?? (Confirmed Town)
14. Dsell - 1-Shot Deathproof/Jadzia-->Ezri Dax

[/quote]

[yuma]

so I guess we are just waiting on Jimmmm and theorel?

[liopoil]

what is a lightning rod?

[mcmcsalot]

it attracts all night kills to you so all kills, all protections, all investigations.

Uses include, if there is only one nk and there is a medic, you can cancel the nk automatically. Yuma mentioned in a game like this with multiple nk's you would reduce the nk's to one.